The Democratic Party is all about rewarding bad behavior and punishing positive behavior. I find it hard to find counter examples.
Concerned Tax Payer wrote:
Big mistake. I know it sounds like a great idea, but it actually is counterproductive.
Students who take intelligent courses (meaning course that prepare that to get a good job) will be punished. They will earn enough to pay back their loans.
However, students that take courses that don't provide for a sound career (major's like art history - we only need a few people to manage museums and teach art history - after those jobs are filled, what will you do?) will not earn enough money to pay back their loans. So the tax payers get stuck with the bill.
In essence, we are rewarding people to make poor choices, instead of intelligent choices. If we want people take the tough courses - medical, engineering, sciences, accounting, etc then why do we make them pay their own way, while we let people who made poor choices off the hook.
I'm not suggesting we don't help students - but we need to reward the right people, not the wrong people. The real question is why is college costing so much? Cost of college continues to increase at faster rates than inflation. Why?
For one thing student loans are a disaster. Since students can get the money, colleges keep raising their fees. If there were no loans - I guarantee college costs would come down. We give colleges no incentive to control costs. In fact, over the last few years - administrative costs are going up the fastest.
If you want to help our economy - give scholarships for degrees that we want filled. There are shortages in engineering and sciences - well give those students a scholarship to make those course more attractive in the short-term. Besides many of those course take more than 4 years so it costs more for those degrees.
We need to think - if we want to help students - help the right ones or help steer students to make intelligent decisions. Colleges should have to provide a cost benefit analysis for any degree major - if students saw those numbers they might not want to take a college major that earns less than $15 an hour - what fast employees think they are worth.
Big mistake. I know it sounds like a great idea, ... (
show quote)