One Political Plaza - Home of politics
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main
Thanksgiving,another American myth
Page <prev 2 of 27 next> last>>
Nov 25, 2013 09:44:28   #
permafrost Loc: Minnesota
 
Jon, nice post..Interesting and on the point..will have to look up that Brundage picture...

Reply
Nov 25, 2013 09:49:40   #
Searching Loc: Rural Southwest VA
 
jonhatfield wrote:
Ghost and a sizable part of the extremist right who post on OPP use this kind of language all the time. Bathroom talk is apparently a thing with them--almost a stereotype for them. ha. Don't expect much better from the venters. I should talk--I constantly refer to their paranoia, conspiracy fantasies, and call them "rightwingnuts"--not exactly nice. Now, "filthy-minded" is a term that can fairly be applied to Ghost and one or two others and I'm sure they wouldn't mind. That's just how they are. Wouldn't you like to have them for neighbors? na.
Ghost and a sizable part of the extremist right wh... (show quote)


You are too funny and yes, I'm sure Ghost and a few others are rather pleased with the terms others have come to describe them by -- like a badge of honor. It certainly does get them noticed and leaves no doubt in the reader's mind as to where they stand!! Hey, different strokes. I should have recognized instantaneously "their patter" for what it is, because I grew up in a household of the same ilk. By the way, I think some of their relatives live close to me :lol:

Reply
Nov 25, 2013 10:08:56   #
Constitutional libertarian Loc: St Croix National Scenic River Way
 
jonhatfield wrote:
Ghost and a sizable part of the extremist right who post on OPP use this kind of language all the time. Bathroom talk is apparently a thing with them--almost a stereotype for them. ha. Don't expect much better from the venters. I should talk--I constantly refer to their paranoia, conspiracy fantasies, and call them "rightwingnuts"--not exactly nice. Now, "filthy-minded" is a term that can fairly be applied to Ghost and one or two others and I'm sure they wouldn't mind. That's just how they are. Wouldn't you like to have them for neighbors? na.
Ghost and a sizable part of the extremist right wh... (show quote)


Jon, you could do much worse than having neighbors who know right from wrong, aren't cooking meth or playing polar bear hunting with your wife or daughter.

Reply
 
 
Nov 25, 2013 10:27:31   #
jonhatfield Loc: Green Bay, WI
 
permafrost wrote:
Jon, nice post..Interesting and on the point..will have to look up that Brundage picture...


I received the Brundage tradecard greeting from a kind late friend who had the largest and best collection of Brundage publication. I haven't seen this image anywhere else--early 1890s publication rarely shows up. My friend co-authored a major collector book on Brundage several years ago but acquired this piece after that book. Perhaps if you can figure out the private message system with OPP, perhaps send an address for me to send a photocopy of the image to you. It is a remarkable image of the American ideal. I've thought of sending it to the State Department for use as one picture and proof of the American idea.

Reply
Nov 25, 2013 10:54:25   #
RetNavyCWO Loc: VA suburb of DC
 
jonhatfield wrote:
I received the Brundage tradecard greeting from a kind late friend who had the largest and best collection of Brundage publication. I haven't seen this image anywhere else--early 1890s publication rarely shows up. My friend co-authored a major collector book on Brundage several years ago but acquired this piece after that book. Perhaps if you can figure out the private message system with OPP, perhaps send an address for me to send a photocopy of the image to you. It is a remarkable image of the American ideal. I've thought of sending it to the State Department for use as one picture and proof of the American idea.
I received the Brundage tradecard greeting from a ... (show quote)


As you described that picture, I couldn't help but recall how we were taught in school as children that America is a "melting pot" in which people from around the world come here and turn into conforming Americans. I don't think that metaphor is used any more...and for good reason! It was more wishful thinking than reality. Yes, some melting occurs, but ethnicities who immigrate here, both today and back during the heyday of Ellis Island and before, tend to seek out their own kind and form their own communities, even if the individual members of those communities are scattered throughout society. I don't think there is anything wrong with that, either. There is nothing wrong with people being proud of their heritage, and we are a more diverse and educated society because of it. Still ... there is, and has been, a lot of bigotry and intolerance between the individual groups. I think we will eventually melt together, but we are not there yet.

Reply
Nov 25, 2013 11:07:02   #
jonhatfield Loc: Green Bay, WI
 
Constitutional libertarian wrote:
Jon, you could do much worse than having neighbors who know right from wrong, aren't cooking meth or playing polar bear hunting with your wife or daughter.


Quite frankly I don't think I would like living in a neighborhood where Ghost and those who talk like him live. I suspect that neighborhood would have neighbors cooking meth or playing polar bear (wh**ever that is)--in fact I wouldn't be that surprised if Halloween Bugaboo and his kind were cooking meth & playing polar bear themselves.

I live in a nice middle class Green Bay neighborhood, thank you, where people do not talk filth and aren't filthy and do know right from wrong. I've lived over long periods in two rural small towns where I knew everyone and they knew me, various social class circumstances, and never once encountered that kind of talk or filthy people.

Ghost and company give a new stereotype for extreme rightwing--filthy. Sorry, that's totally unfair to most of the extreme right--unfortunately true for too many. I shouldn't stereotype, but Bugaboo has put himself in the uncouth category himself...again and again. Yuck.

By the way, this nice middle-class Green Bay neighborhood we live in had mostly Obama signs in the yards last November. Very nice conventional mainstream middle class neighborhood, thank you.

Reply
Nov 25, 2013 11:32:17   #
Hungry Freaks
 
RetNavyCWO wrote:
As you described that picture, I couldn't help but recall how we were taught in school as children that America is a "melting pot" in which people from around the world come here and turn into conforming Americans. I don't think that metaphor is used any more...and for good reason! It was more wishful thinking than reality. Yes, some melting occurs, but ethnicities who immigrate here, both today and back during the heyday of Ellis Island and before, tend to seek out their own kind and form their own communities, even if the individual members of those communities are scattered throughout society. I don't think there is anything wrong with that, either. There is nothing wrong with people being proud of their heritage, and we are a more diverse and educated society because of it. Still ... there is, and has been, a lot of bigotry and intolerance between the individual groups. I think we will eventually melt together, but we are not there yet.
As you described that picture, I couldn't help but... (show quote)


There is much hatred and bigotry toward the newest of immigrants-today it's the Mexicans and Central Americans. IN years past, Jews from Europe, the Irish, the Slavs and the
Germans, not to mention the "Yellow Scares" against Chinese laborers who were working out West.

Time moves on. It's strange to hear guys like Bill O'Reilly speak about "traditional America" when, a hundred years ago, anyone named O'Reilly would, by the more established immigrants, be considered dirty, lazy, with a predilection towards crime, etc-basically what some of the now-established Irish like O'Reilly place on newer immigrants.

We eventually become a melting pot, although the corporate oligarchy tries to stoke the flames of racial hatred to keep Middle Class Americans divided. I've just purchased a book "The Next American Nation" in which author Michael Lind apparently speaks of the false divides in the US and the need to rise above multi-culturalism and work as a single group connected by common economic interests-at least that's what it looks like from the first 50 pages or so. He seems to have distain fro he left and the right, the former pushing for a multi-cultural society that supplants common action and the right, which he claims use the fear of m**************m to block "t***s-m**************m" to again divide and conquer the Middle Class, one made up of all racial and ethnic groups.

Reply
 
 
Nov 25, 2013 11:34:25   #
Hungry Freaks
 
PS: Chief WO: I think this "The Next American nation" is mostly likely exactly what you're talking about. I'll know more as I get into further.

Reply
Nov 25, 2013 11:35:20   #
Constitutional libertarian Loc: St Croix National Scenic River Way
 
RetNavyCWO wrote:
As you described that picture, I couldn't help but recall how we were taught in school as children that America is a "melting pot" in which people from around the world come here and turn into conforming Americans. I don't think that metaphor is used any more...and for good reason! It was more wishful thinking than reality. Yes, some melting occurs, but ethnicities who immigrate here, both today and back during the heyday of Ellis Island and before, tend to seek out their own kind and form their own communities, even if the individual members of those communities are scattered throughout society. I don't think there is anything wrong with that, either. There is nothing wrong with people being proud of their heritage, and we are a more diverse and educated society because of it. Still ... there is, and has been, a lot of bigotry and intolerance between the individual groups. I think we will eventually melt together, but we are not there yet.
As you described that picture, I couldn't help but... (show quote)


I think you are mistaken on the melting thing when you are talking most europeans. Their were many groups hostile to other groups back in the late 1800's and early 20th century that are completely gone today. I think many Asian cultures have blended into our form of capitalism quite well and today have very little problems with bigotry or r****m.

There is still a fair bit with some of the newer immigrants like
Somalians even within the Muslim community because their culture is so radically different from the majority of Americans. But they too will eventually become apart of the larger American way of life.

But the biggest question is that of African Americans. We all came here to give our children a better future including native Americans to a certain extent. But that is not the case for most African Americans. Have they made huge strides absolutely even to a point of some reverse discrimination. It's much easier getting certain jobs if your a black woman than a white male. I'm not saying this is good or bad just fact. So why ??? Why do b****s have so much higher unemployment or much lower high school graduation rates.

Go on there is an answer and a cause that must be openly addressed without fear of being called a r****t.

The government has taken socially engineered a culture devoid of personal responsibility for family, children and community. The basic human structure has broken down and until the damage is repaired there will be in equalities between most other family centric groups and those that no longer are.

This goes for w****s as well if we continue down this self destructive path.

Reply
Nov 25, 2013 11:40:38   #
Hungry Freaks
 
Jon Hatfield: Thanks for the thoughtful posts of you and the Chief WO. It's easy to reply in kind to the tinfoil hat crowd, but it rarely does any good. I have neighbors who are right-wing r****t folks who have no respect for my rights as a property owner-they constantly trespassed on my property with their ATVs until they saw exactly what measures I would take to stop them. Fear is the only thing these people understand. The live in a world of fear-of other racial groups, of anyone who doesn't seek entertainment or spiritual fulfillment as they do, from people who have different political ideas.

Green Bay always struck me as an ideal community-the Green Bay Packers are an example of what every team in the NFL-or any other major league sport-should be-community owned.

Now if you can only get Aaron Rodgers healthy.

Reply
Nov 25, 2013 12:16:58   #
Hungry Freaks
 
Constitutional libertarian wrote:
I think you are mistaken on the melting thing when you are talking most europeans. Their were many groups hostile to other groups back in the late 1800's and early 20th century that are completely gone today. I think many Asian cultures have blended into our form of capitalism quite well and today have very little problems with bigotry or r****m.

There is still a fair bit with some of the newer immigrants like
Somalians even within the Muslim community because their culture is so radically different from the majority of Americans. But they too will eventually become apart of the larger American way of life.

But the biggest question is that of African Americans. We all came here to give our children a better future including native Americans to a certain extent. But that is not the case for most African Americans. Have they made huge strides absolutely even to a point of some reverse discrimination. It's much easier getting certain jobs if your a black woman than a white male. I'm not saying this is good or bad just fact. So why ??? Why do b****s have so much higher unemployment or much lower high school graduation rates.

Go on there is an answer and a cause that must be openly addressed without fear of being called a r****t.

The government has taken socially engineered a culture devoid of personal responsibility for family, children and community. The basic human structure has broken down and until the damage is repaired there will be in equalities between most other family centric groups and those that no longer are.

This goes for w****s as well if we continue down this self destructive path.
I think you are mistaken on the melting thing when... (show quote)


There's a reason why the issue of former black s***es was called "White Man's Burden." Africans were brought he in chains, not as humans, but as property. Their diets were fatty and protein poor. they were bred like horses or other animals rather than allowed to choose their own spouses and live with their families. Black women were routinely raped by White owners. They had their names, cultural identity and languages taken from them.

African Americans were essential to the building of what America is today-they were the labor in the growing of cotton, sugar cane (in the Islands) and tobacco crops, the three commodities that made the America's rich. Although African Americans were "freed" after the Civil War, they lived in virtual s***ery (at least in the Deep South ) until 40 or 50 years ago.

Many of the problems that plague African Americans are now-community-based-problems of black on black crime, the "gansta" ethos that gives a social stigma, at least among his peers, for an African American male to achieve scholastically.

Instead of giving African Americans an equal chance, most were bought of by Great Society programs that offered a pittance of financial support rather than an even chance to achieve a steady job, education, etc.

Worst of all, desegregation allowed the Upper and Middle Class African Americans to leave their communities, resulting in ghettos of lower class African Americans that now populate many inner-city neighborhoods.

The answer-I have no idea. But African Americans are a special group that has given us much of our culture, including jazz, the blues, rock and roll, all that have been exported to Britain and Europe for cultural consumption. As Sonny Boy Williamson, a Black bluesman who moved to England in the 1960s, said: "these British boys want to play the blues so badly...and they do." The Rolling Stones, Eric Clapton and a host of other British rock legends owe a measure of their success to American bluesmen who never saw a fraction of the financial rewards that Mick and the boys received. It seems to be a re-ocurring theme in the history of African Americans.

Reply
 
 
Nov 25, 2013 12:18:35   #
Constitutional libertarian Loc: St Croix National Scenic River Way
 
jonhatfield wrote:
Quite frankly I don't think I would like living in a neighborhood where Ghost and those who talk like him live. I suspect that neighborhood would have neighbors cooking meth or playing polar bear (wh**ever that is)--in fact I wouldn't be that surprised if Halloween Bugaboo and his kind were cooking meth & playing polar bear themselves.

I live in a nice middle class Green Bay neighborhood, thank you, where people do not talk filth and aren't filthy and do know right from wrong. I've lived over long periods in two rural small towns where I knew everyone and they knew me, various social class circumstances, and never once encountered that kind of talk or filthy people.

Ghost and company give a new stereotype for extreme rightwing--filthy. Sorry, that's totally unfair to most of the extreme right--unfortunately true for too many. I shouldn't stereotype, but Bugaboo has put himself in the uncouth category himself...again and again. Yuck.

By the way, this nice middle-class Green Bay neighborhood we live in had mostly Obama signs in the yards last November. Very nice conventional mainstream middle class neighborhood, thank you.
Quite frankly I don't think I would like living in... (show quote)


I don't get to Green Bay often once twice on my way to door county. I'm sure it's nice other than being a bit to cheesy for my Scandinavian leanings. To bad about yesterday lol.

Yes, there is a bit of over zealous extremism by many on this sight including myself at times. But i don't think Obama would have won last year had the people known the t***h about the ACA especially in WI given how many people stand with conservatives like Walker. I too lived in a nice mostly blue collar suburban neighborhood for 20 plus years. You would think they would have been more left than your normal trades oriented community but it wasn't. We saw what government intrusion into our community meant and what it's effects were and you saw many more Romney than Obama.

Am I a right wing nut, I don't think so I just want us to continue to have to future our children that our ancestors came here to achieve.

Reply
Nov 25, 2013 12:22:56   #
Constitutional libertarian Loc: St Croix National Scenic River Way
 
Constitutional libertarian wrote:
I don't get to Green Bay often once twice on my way to door county. I'm sure it's nice other than being a bit to cheesy for my Scandinavian leanings. To bad about yesterday lol.

Yes, there is a bit of over zealous extremism by many on this sight including myself at times. But i don't think Obama would have won last year had the people known the t***h about the ACA especially in WI given how many people stand with conservatives like Walker. I too lived in a nice mostly blue collar suburban neighborhood for 20 plus years. You would think they would have been more left being such a trade oriented community but it wasn't. We saw what government intrusion into our community meant and what it's effects were and you saw many more Romney than Obama. It may have been because they were the business owners rather than the employees.

Am I a right wing nut, I don't think so I just want us to continue to have the future for our children that our ancestors came here to achieve.
I don't get to Green Bay often once twice on my wa... (show quote)

Reply
Nov 25, 2013 12:32:53   #
stymie
 
ginnyt wrote:
It is sad when I see things like this. People who have lost their p***e, people who are bitter, people who want to tarnish the last remnants of history. In this day and age, if you do not like what is written as history, simply take to your computer and rewrite it. It is simple, disregard what the history books tell, after all we all know that none of the original settlers are here to be asked, so write what you want. My family first came to these shores in 1669 and I have their diaries. Those accounts are quite different than what you find in the new and improved history books such as the one you recommend. My forefathers were not "debtor, prisons, jails and rounded up religious fanatics" they were simple people looking for a better way of life. Many people came here in the same way as my forefathers; honest people, people with p***e, dignity, and respect for each other and the land they came to call home.

Remember when you group all people together and label them, then you become no better than those who say that b****s are lazy thieves who lay around looking for their next welfare check, or those who say find an Indian and you can find a drunk, or.....I think you get the idea. Yes, there are very dark and horrible people that came to the "New World" along side of those who came for freedom. As there are very dark and horrible people that roamed Africa looking to kidnap their own kind and sell them to s***ery, and least we forget the "native American" who would toss the wives out of tribes when their husbands were k**led. And our Mexicans who participated in cannibalism. Yes. Horrible people lived and born in their place were replacements that are just as horrible. But, I am thankful that there are more good people in this world than those poor reached souls. Let us not forget, the people who settled in what is now the United States has built a nation that is generous of heart, tolerant of differences, and have done more than any other nation to improve the plight of mankind.

My recommendation, take you new and improved history books, pack your suitcase and head to someplace that you can form a sense of belonging, p***e in association, and love for the land.
It is sad when I see things like this. People who... (show quote)


Well said!! :thumbup: :thumbup: :thumbup:
Inyourface has some serious issues, I really hope he is not a gun owner.

Reply
Nov 25, 2013 13:02:04   #
permafrost Loc: Minnesota
 
jonhatfield wrote:
I received the Brundage tradecard greeting from a kind late friend who had the largest and best collection of Brundage publication. I haven't seen this image anywhere else--early 1890s publication rarely shows up. My friend co-authored a major collector book on Brundage several years ago but acquired this piece after that book. Perhaps if you can figure out the private message system with OPP, perhaps send an address for me to send a photocopy of the image to you. It is a remarkable image of the American ideal. I've thought of sending it to the State Department for use as one picture and proof of the American idea.
I received the Brundage tradecard greeting from a ... (show quote)

Have had some computer problem after I started on this site..no idea if related to this use..but when I go to the PM page I am looking at instructions to down load a toolbar and am a bit leery of adding anything to my clunker of a PC..has anyone using the PM page have any hints, advise, ridicule any info at all would be appreciated. Did I miss a help page on it?

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 27 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main
OnePoliticalPlaza.com - Forum
Copyright 2012-2024 IDF International Technologies, Inc.