One Political Plaza - Home of politics
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main
At what point are we "beings?"
Page <<first <prev 18 of 21 next> last>>
May 23, 2019 15:55:26   #
whitnebrat Loc: In the wilds of Oregon
 
Blade_Runner wrote:
It is the height of arrogance for a human being to assume the authority to determine the value of another human's life based only on that person's health, social status, or economic circumstances.

All men are created equal.. they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights . . . among these are LIFE, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness . . . .

Theoretical ideas aren't reflected in reality. It doesn't matter that we should treat all equal ... the t***h is that we aren't treated that way. It happens every day. While you may consider it arrogant or not doesn't alter the fact that it's going on as we speak.

Reply
May 23, 2019 15:59:42   #
Blade_Runner Loc: DARK SIDE OF THE MOON
 
whitnebrat wrote:
Theoretical ideas aren't reflected in reality. It doesn't matter that we should treat all equal ... the t***h is that we aren't treated that way. It happens every day. While you may consider it arrogant or not doesn't alter the fact that it's going on as we speak.


Yeah, I know. May God have mercy on the humanist progressives who have brought this plague upon us.

Reply
May 23, 2019 17:40:07   #
Morgan
 
Rose42 wrote:
Do you believe we are here by choice? A friend of mine believes our soul existed before we were born but he’s never mentioned a choice.


One theory~possibility, I was told decades ago, was that we come to earth with an agreed contract, that we choose our parents, all of this is not in our memory, we go through life making our choices along with their consequences and rewards. This coincides with people who believe in reincarnation. Part of the Jewish belief is the well of souls and though they believe in God they also believe in reincarnation.

To answer your question, yes I believe we do have a choice whether to return or not.

Reply
 
 
May 23, 2019 17:42:10   #
eagleye13 Loc: Fl
 
whitnebrat wrote:
Theoretical ideas aren't reflected in reality. It doesn't matter that we should treat all equal ... the t***h is that we aren't treated that way. It happens every day. While you may consider it arrogant or not doesn't alter the fact that it's going on as we speak.


whitnebrat; can you name another country that come close to America in treating its people equally?

Reply
May 23, 2019 17:45:28   #
Rose42
 
Morgan wrote:
One theory~possibility, I was told decades ago, was that we come to earth with an agreed contract, that we choose our parents, all of this is not in our memory, we go through life making our choices along with their consequences and rewards. This coincides with people who believe in reincarnation. Part of the Jewish belief is the well of souls and though they believe in God they also believe in reincarnation.

To answer your question, yes I believe we do have a choice whether to return or not.
One theory~possibility, I was told decades ago, wa... (show quote)


I have not heard it put that way before - thanks for answering. No beating from me.

Reply
May 23, 2019 17:52:11   #
Morgan
 
nwtk2007 wrote:
When I was a kid I sort of thought of the earth as a filtering place for spirits/souls, as if on earth the true being would be revealed and God would then choose from amongst those for his other greater "duties." I still sort of hold that idea in the back of my mind. But, it makes me feel that I have failed myself when my short comings are revealed. So, I'm hoping for a re-do in another life and maybe that is possible too, sort of like the beliefs that with each life we draw nearer to the final destination of being what God intends us to be.
When I was a kid I sort of thought of the earth as... (show quote)


That is my understanding, that souls can achieve a higher plateau of consciousness in divineness. I h**e to think of people feeling that they have failed, mistakes are made yes, but that is exactly when we learn, grow and expand. I believe the Divine is not singular and sees us all as babes in the woods, such simpletons we are, LOL... even with our oh so great technology.

Reply
May 23, 2019 18:12:35   #
whitnebrat Loc: In the wilds of Oregon
 
eagleye13 wrote:
whitnebrat; can you name another country that come close to America in treating its people equally?

Not sure, but Denmark and Sweden come to mind ...

Reply
 
 
May 23, 2019 18:56:31   #
Canuckus Deploracus Loc: North of the wall
 
whitnebrat wrote:
Not sure, but Denmark and Sweden come to mind ...


Canada

Reply
May 24, 2019 01:20:53   #
JW
 
Blade_Runner wrote:
I posed some questions about future possibilities.

You are making some outlandish assumptions. How do you know a growth inside a woman is insentient? Can you prove that? How do you know that the existence of a soul is unprovable? Just because science has not yet provided empirical evidence one way or the other, who's to say one day it won't?

Besides, science is not the only path to knowledge. The statement that science is the only way to t***h contradicts itself because that statement has no basis in science.
I posed some questions about future possibilities.... (show quote)


Point 1: Not only is science the only road to knowledge, science is knowledge. It's what the word means.

Point 2: Sentience is the ability to perceive things or minimally to be able to feel things. If sentience goes by the second sense, to feel things, every living thing would be sentient and that renders the word meaningless. The Venus Fly Trap and other plants can feel things. Consequently, feeling things must mean in the sense of perception for it to have any actual meaning. I think it fair to say that knowledge is the only way to t***h.

To perceive in the sense of a sentient creature requires minimally a central nervous system. A zygote doesn't have one. A foetus doesn't even have anything that begins to resemble a mammalian brain until the sixth month of gestation.

If it is your contention that a soul enters at the moment of conception, we are back at your religious beliefs again and I repeat my question; by what authority do you subject a nonsubscriber to your religious viewpoint.

Reply
May 24, 2019 06:49:33   #
Morgan
 
whitnebrat wrote:
Not sure, but Denmark and Sweden come to mind ...


Except according to polls taken those people are happier, Denmark has rated highest in the world for people happiest with where they live.

Reply
May 24, 2019 06:52:25   #
Morgan
 
Canuckus Deploracus wrote:
Canada


...and why are you living in China? Just jerking your chain my friend, lol

Reply
 
 
May 24, 2019 07:03:38   #
lindajoy Loc: right here with you....
 
JW wrote:
lindajoy: Faith can not be defined in spirituality..It simply is... Just as you have faith in your wife or child, if you have either, or simply faith in yourself..

Interesting debate and while there is no proof as you say about God, you nor anyone else has proof there isn’t a God..

Its choices made by the person in their personal beliefs.. We believe, you do not.. So be it...


… but, I really do/did not expect a response.


Beliefs are personal things as you say and, as long as they don't affect the unwilling, should be free to be held and be beyond the reproach of the unconcerned. Belief is a major problem for objectivity. Where belief governs, objectivity vanishes.

This thread, as I undeerstood it, was not about religion but about a quality of existence. I've tried to respond to that as best I can.
lindajoy: Faith can not be defined in spirituality... (show quote)


You have replied to the life question very well I might add..

I’ll only say belief causes things to happen in our lives... An inward convictions, a feeling of reality and motives us in many aspects of life..

Belief and objectivity makes for very interesting debates~~

Reply
May 24, 2019 07:06:23   #
Morgan
 
JW wrote:
Point 1: Not only is science the only road to knowledge, science is knowledge. It's what the word means.

Point 2: Sentience is the ability to perceive things or minimally to be able to feel things. If sentience goes by the second sense, to feel things, every living thing would be sentient and that renders the word meaningless. The Venus Fly Trap and other plants can feel things. Consequently, feeling things must mean in the sense of perception for it to have any actual meaning. I think it fair to say that knowledge is the only way to t***h.

To perceive in the sense of a sentient creature requires minimally a central nervous system. A zygote doesn't have one. A foetus doesn't even have anything that begins to resemble a mammalian brain until the sixth month of gestation.

If it is your contention that a soul enters at the moment of conception, we are back at your religious beliefs again and I repeat my question; by what authority do you subject a nonsubscriber to your religious viewpoint.
Point 1: Not only is science the only road to know... (show quote)


That is what it comes down to, the religious pushing their viewpoint to how we all abide by. This is not a governmental issue, a very personal, morally individual issue. Using this issue for the government to decide is opening a Pandora's Box, though they don't see it.

Reply
May 24, 2019 07:10:16   #
Morgan
 
Rose42 wrote:
I have not heard it put that way before - thanks for answering. No beating from me.


Thank you

Reply
May 24, 2019 07:17:14   #
Rose42
 
Morgan wrote:
That is what it comes down to, the religious pushing their viewpoint to how we all abide by.


Isn’t the opposite also true?

Science is like a religion to many. Its not the only path to knowledge. There are many things it can’t begin to explain and it bends with trends in society.

Reply
Page <<first <prev 18 of 21 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main
OnePoliticalPlaza.com - Forum
Copyright 2012-2024 IDF International Technologies, Inc.