One Political Plaza - Home of politics
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main
What is a Patriot?
Page <<first <prev 5 of 19 next> last>>
Jun 17, 2019 23:46:00   #
rumitoid
 
The Critical Critic wrote:
You’re welcome, Rumi, happy you enjoyed the article. Coos Bay Tom triggered my memory of the article, as it seemed the subject interested him quite a bit. Great topic for discussion on your part.


You are a smart guy with great things to contribute. Thank you again. Was hoping this thread may actually garner some real and lively debate instead of the usual hate and insult. You gave much to think about.

Reply
Jun 18, 2019 00:02:00   #
The Critical Critic Loc: Turtle Island
 
rumitoid wrote:
You are a smart guy with great things to contribute. Thank you again.

Thank you for the kind words. We may not see eye to eye on some things but, I assure you the sentiment is reciprocated.
Quote:
Was hoping this thread may actually garner some real and lively debate instead of the usual hate and insult.

The potential is still there, sometimes (as I’m sure you’re aware) it just takes a couple of pages.

Reply
Jun 18, 2019 00:15:33   #
rumitoid
 
The Critical Critic wrote:
The potential is still there, sometimes (as I’m sure you’re aware) it just takes a couple of pages.


Yes, so true. If we stick around.

Reply
 
 
Jun 18, 2019 00:34:24   #
dilibar
 
You leftists are all insane! You are banning EVERYTHING this country stands for! Y'all need to be sent to Quantico with all your anti-Semitic and killer Muslims! The good side...just means closer to Jesus' return...YEAH!

Reply
Jun 18, 2019 00:51:42   #
rumitoid
 
dilibar wrote:
You leftists are all insane! You are banning EVERYTHING this country stands for! Y'all need to be sent to Quantico with all your anti-Semitic and killer Muslims! The good side...just means closer to Jesus' return...YEAH!


Is that patriotism talking?

Reply
Jun 18, 2019 03:10:52   #
JoyV
 
Coos Bay Tom wrote:
To me Patriotism means defending the American way of life. Another thing is defending the constitutional rights of ALL Americans weather you agree with them or not.


Exactly!!!

Reply
Jun 18, 2019 03:13:41   #
JoyV
 
JW wrote:
It is a very simple question. Better stated, do you want your country, your culture, to survive and persist?

If you do, then you are obliged to stand up for your country. You "father" your country, as it were.

"Root of Patriot
Patriotism. The word patriot comes from Latin; the root is the same as that of "father": pater; also French patrie . "

A good father is willing to die for his family but is not in haste to do so. A patriot is willing to die for his country but is equally unwilling to rush to it.

Those chauvinists who glory in the idea of a heroic death, usually someone else's, sometimes called super-patriots, are as dangerous to the survival of a nation as are those who condemn patriotism or see no need for it.

BTW - It was Ambrose Bierce who coined the phrase you attribute to Samuel Johnson.
It is a very simple question. Better stated, do yo... (show quote)


Thanks for correcting Rumitoid on the quote. I knew it didn't sound like something Samuel Johnson would say.

Reply
 
 
Jun 18, 2019 03:25:58   #
JoyV
 
Morgan wrote:
This is when patriotism gets twisted and morphed into Nationalism. Love for country is still a good thing, blind loyalty to a person is not.


Since when is blind loyalty to a person, Nationalism. Nationalism is love for your nation above any other nation. Not that you think you or your nations citizens are inherently superior, but simply that you want your nation to succeed more than any other. And by succeed it could mean be have more liberty, have better justice, have a stronger economy, have better education, or have a healthier population. Patriotism and Nationalism are intrinsically linked. You CANNOT be a nationalist without being a patriot.

Reply
Jun 18, 2019 03:44:16   #
JoyV
 
rumitoid wrote:
That is a troubling and highly complex question. If we want to see patriotism as a good thing, than we have to see that all patriotism, even that of our enemies or any others, as equally good. This is the book definition of Patriotism: "the quality of being patriotic; devotion to and vigorous support for one's country." Yet "devotion and vigorous support" means what? Or the simple definition of patriotism as "love of country" means what?

Patriotism is to me a sham; it does not come close to truth on the matter. Samuel Johnson said that it was the last refuge of the scoundrel, yet Boswell, his biographical commentator, gave no context. Let me provide one, my own.

Basically, there is absolutely no need for patriotism. America has ideals and principles and values that we honor and protect. Why? Because if we have integrity those same ideals and principles and values reflect what we stand for as individuals. It is not a dedication to borders or a flag but to the heart and spirit of liberty. If America strayed from these things, as much as another country threatened them, we would be equally zealous, "devoted and vigorous," in rooting out the corrupting influence. This is something the Right does not seem to understand.

Patriotism appears to mean to the Right lock-step loyalty to Trump and abject hatred for the Left. This is what is so totally bad about patriotism. It has no parameters. Such thoughts as those are not for the country or its principles but for party or a man. The word patriotism or patriot should be forever banned as being anything more than a poor and shaky description of multiple and perhaps conflicting feelings regarding a nation.
That is a troubling and highly complex question. I... (show quote)


Ideals, principals and values need not be based on one's nation. In fact most ideals and principals are not exclusive to any particular nation. But what do ideals and principals, no matter how laudable, have to do with patriotism -- not to mention, those can change.

As for patriotism being bad because others from other nations who may be enemies or act in despicable ways might be patriotic to their own countries; so what? That would be like saying since Hitler was a vegetarian, all vegetarianism is evil. When Americans say they are patriotic, it goes without saying that they mean they are patriotic to America, not Iran!

If you want to ban American patriotism you either want a one world order, eliminating Americans as an identifiable group; or you want to surrender American to another country making Americans subservient to others, enslaving Americans. And if you want a one world order, you can bet there will be those who consider themselves to be the elite who will be the masters of everyone else.

Being loyal to any one president is not what it means to be an American patriot, no matter how good a job that president is doing. An American Patriot is loyal first to the Constitution of the United States. BECAUSE they are loyal to our constitution, they are loyal to our elected President no matter who holds that office (so long as that president keeps his oath to defend and protect the Constitution of the United States!)

Reply
Jun 18, 2019 04:04:10   #
Ricktloml
 
[quote=JoyV]Ideals, principals and values need not be based on one's nation. In fact most ideals and principals are not exclusive to any particular nation. But what do ideals and principals, no matter how laudable, have to do with patriotism -- not to mention, those can change.

As for patriotism being bad because others from other nations who may be enemies or act in despicable ways might be patriotic to their own countries; so what? That would be like saying since Hitler was a vegetarian, all vegetarianism is evil. When Americans say they are patriotic, it goes without saying that they mean they are patriotic to America, not Iran!

If you want to ban American patriotism you either want a one world order, eliminating Americans as an identifiable group; or you want to surrender American to another country making Americans subservient to others, enslaving Americans. And if you want a one world order, you can bet there will be those who consider themselves to be the elite who will be the masters of everyone else.

Being loyal to any one president is not what it means to be an American patriot, no matter how good a job that president is doing. An American Patriot is loyal first to the Constitution of the United States. BECAUSE they are loyal to our constitution, they are loyal to our elected President no matter who holds that office (so long as that president keeps his oath to defend and protect the Constitution of the United States!)[/quote

Well said JoyV. Much has been made of the divisiveness surrounding today's politics, and how a house divided cannot stand, and the affixing of blame. But it is and has been the left and their collaborative media that has been dividing this nation for decades. Quite frankly conservatism and at least still a few in the Republican Party are a bigger threat to the left's "fundamental transformation" of this country. The left has no intention of working together with the "loyal opposition". Because as they have stated, and their policies reflect there is very little common ground to be had with groups who hate the country enough to change it "fundamentally". The left has more allegiance to our enemies and since they lost the last elections are willing to do ANYTHING, no matter the harm to the country to punish the citizens who attempted to curb their power. President Trump's policies have resulted in extremely low unemployment rates, a booming economy, and an attempt to institute border security, which the leftist Democrat/socialist Party, (and the sell-out RINOs have blocked repeatedly,) all while being framed by the previous administration in the worst corruption and abuse of power scandal in American history. And those on the left have the nerve to question President Trump, OR his supporters' patriotism.

Reply
Jun 18, 2019 06:27:34   #
lindajoy Loc: right here with you....
 
badbobby wrote:
Do you really feel that our service men from every war our country has waged were not patriots?
These patriots gave up their arms ,legs,their sight and even their very lives standing up for our country
I am a patriot
I believe in this nation
my country right or wrong
I am a patriot


Yes Sir you certainly are!!! 🇺🇸🇺🇸💫

Reply
 
 
Jun 18, 2019 06:28:26   #
lindajoy Loc: right here with you....
 
badbobby wrote:
since you are in the USA
you have a right to your opinion
but you don't have a clue to my feelings


Amen!!!

Reply
Jun 18, 2019 06:50:57   #
Morgan
 
The Critical Critic wrote:
Agreed. A daunting task, which is sad considering the technology of today that makes communication almost instantaneous. Thinking the issue has more to do with comprehension, and finding agreement without conforming or temporarily suspending core beliefs and values.


Yes, I too think its comprehension but in defense, we are manipulated with a constant feed of slanted information and opinion pieces rather just stating the simple facts on the occurrences of events. People are overly busy and exhausted to take the time to file through the misinformation. Not to mention their disgusted attitude which is justified, so what do they do, they go to their go-to spot and eat it up, falling right into the hole of being manipulated thereby allowing the cycle to continue.

I believe the responsibility should fall on the journalists to go back to the days of being more factual and not slanting the truths. Maybe slander should be more accountable.

Reply
Jun 18, 2019 07:04:54   #
Morgan
 
JoyV wrote:
Since when is blind loyalty to a person, Nationalism. Nationalism is love for your nation above any other nation. Not that you think you or your nations citizens are inherently superior, but simply that you want your nation to succeed more than any other. And by succeed it could mean be have more liberty, have better justice, have a stronger economy, have better education, or have a healthier population. Patriotism and Nationalism are intrinsically linked. You CANNOT be a nationalist without being a patriot.
Since when is blind loyalty to a person, Nationali... (show quote)


Nationalism is fine as long as it stays within reason and not to the extreme as we've seen it done before with Hitler and Germany. It is important to be sure that self interest in promoting the country doesn't over ride any of its citizens, or have their construed obligations outweigh other individuals or group interests.

Reply
Jun 18, 2019 07:07:16   #
Morgan
 
dilibar wrote:
You leftists are all insane! You are banning EVERYTHING this country stands for! Y'all need to be sent to Quantico with all your anti-Semitic and killer Muslims! The good side...just means closer to Jesus' return...YEAH!


sigh

Reply
Page <<first <prev 5 of 19 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main
OnePoliticalPlaza.com - Forum
Copyright 2012-2024 IDF International Technologies, Inc.