manning5me wrote:
So, we have Give it Up Ritter calling for surrender. We are in Plan A now, not any so-called Plan B or surrender.
The west needs time to reach high volume production of shells and all the other war weapons the Ukraine needs. I'd say about 18 months. We must see them through this cycle with all we can send them to stem the Russian tide. I say to condemn the Ukrainian people to a Russian occupation is to commit genocide for a million Ukranians under Russian rule. We cannot stand by and let this happen as it surely will if you examine the acts of the Russian army over the past years since 1945 in their some 14 wars or interventions. They have proven their total disregard for the lives of Ukrainians be raining missiles on them continuously, taking out people, buildings, homes, and infrastructure. Mr. Ritter wants us to withdraw and sue for peace, I say that is absolutely the worst possible step we might take on at least two counts: 1. humanitarian needs of the people; and, 2. the geopolitical disaster to the west if the Ukraine falls.
In my post "TheRussian Situation I propose the ultimate Plan A, so I will not repeat it here. Tell Ritter to go pound sand, he doesn't even know the power of NATO today!
So, we have Give it Up Ritter calling for surrende... (
show quote)
Manning5me, you put out a lot of great posts. But you are off on this one. If you have followed Ritter you would know he has a damn good handle on what is happening over there. Any delays in sitting down and negotiating for peace is just k*****g off Ukrainian soldiers and other innocents for no damn good reason.
Russia doesn't dare lose and we can't go to those limits. Especially in a war that we are the primary causes of happening. Yes, America and NATO. If we engaged Russia after the cold war, like we did Japan and Germany after WWII, they would have been great friends for over 30 years. Instead we made promises to never expand NATO, seen as their enemy, and then less then ten years later Clinton broke those promises. And NATO has never slowed down in expanding against those promises. That expansion was never necessary.
We called them the evil Empire. But where they? That was the c*******t USSR. There Empire was dead and they were no longer evil, or c*******t. As a matter of fact, America is leaning more and more c*******t, being led by would be dictators like biden and the progressives, c*******t lite. Now they are becoming great friends with China who is the real evil Empireof today, because we drove then to it.
Think back for a minute. Once the USSR was defeated, or willingly expired around 1990, we no longer had to keep up this war material spending. That military industrial complex needed to still be satisfied. So we kept accusing them if being the Evil Empire. In many ways they tried to be friends. They suggested joining the EU and NATO at different times and were refused. They engaged economically and fueled Europe. They aided us in Afghanistan. They built the Space Station with us and ferried our astronauts there after obama grounded the space shuttle. We had Nuclear treaties with them.
But that was never good enough. America wanted missiles on their border. Poland failed, Ukraine into EU and NATO was next. They offered a great deal through the EU to Ukraine. The western Ukrainians loved it. Putin countered with a better deal and their president accepted Russia's deal. Ukraine was in a great pesition to play both sides against each other.
But western Ukrainians protested. So America/NATO/EU staged a c**p using snipers shooting at both sides to start a war. Their President fled for his life. And Victoria Nuland tried to set up America's choices for their leadership.
Putin saw then going to NATO, NATO missiles on Russia's borders, the loss of their Black Sea port and their SW shipping lanes in jeopardy. They hadn't done anything wrong, but America and NATO was doing what ever it could to strangle Russia on their western borders.
Remember the Red Line obama drew in Syria and then backed down. Well, they drew one on Ukraine. "NEVER NATO". They took Crimea. It was 90 per cent Russians already. And they v**ed to go with Russia. Then Ukraine started to go after the ethnic Russian citizens of Ukraine. They wanted to crush their culture and language. They rebelled. 'Who is this new president'. 'We don't accept an appointed president over the one we elected'. Civil war started and the N**I AZOV m*****a went after them. K*****g 14,000 people in the next 8 years, bombing homes and businesses and torturing prisoners. And America and the west was arming and training them.
What would you have Russia do? These people, mostly civilians, would be crushed. They tried to set up a show of force and biden taunted Putin and sanctioned Russia and many Russians. Do you really think the Big Bear should just cave to these aggressors?
Well, we now have war. Russia's aims from the beginning were some form of autonomy for those provinces under attack, a neutral forever Ukraine, and never NATO and get rid of the N**is. He probably wants a little more now. Four eastern provinces and the land bridge to Crimea. But not much else. He has never indicated any desires to go after Europe. Just protecting Russia's western access to the sea lanes and protecting ethnic Russians.
The Ukrainians have been just as brutal as the Russians whenever they could.
Is that worth another two years of k*****g people who don't want to be in this war, to satisfy NATO and America/bicen/obama. I say hell no. End this damn k*****g now. No funding and they will have to give in and save their countrymen.
And when they exchanged prisoners in the past, the Ukrainians were treated nicely as POWs and not much different then what the Ukrainians did. In surrender, they will be treated nicely. Russia does not want a h**e filled enemy on its border and it will take a long time with maximum efforts on both sides to get past these last ten years. It is way past time to start.
This war never had to happen and we are a major reason it did. These are pretty much the facts as I know them and I have studied this a lot. Get out, save lives, save money (60 billion), start saving America and the dollar from inflation and as the world's reserve currency which is rapidly floating away. Close our border and work on our own internal problems.
Peace Manning5me
Logically Right.