One Political Plaza - Home of politics
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main
This president didn't create this v***s, but...
Page <<first <prev 4 of 4
Apr 6, 2020 20:38:53   #
Canuckus Deploracus Loc: North of the wall
 
Navigator wrote:
1. The US is not China. No American President is going to leave American citizens in a country undergoing an epidemic of a dangerous disease when he can let them return to the relative safety of the US. Given these constraints, the travel ban stopped the other 95% of travelers from China and was therefor was much more effective in limiting spread than no travel ban.


China is still allowing citizens to return home... But there is intensive testing and a fourteen day quarantine...
Allowing citizens to return home is fine... Allowing them out into public without proper testing was not... And that is exactly what happened... Individuals who returned from China were sent home and asked to quarantine... They were tested only if they displayed symptoms... This was well after it was reported that the v***s could spread without the carrier showing symptoms....

Quote:
2. America is the third most populous country in the world and has a lot more people travelling for business and pleasure from the infected region, China, than India and other heavily populated areas like South America and Africa. Although testing started slowly, the US is now leading the world in testing. As a result, America is leading the world in diagnosed cases.


But far fewer than Japan, Korea, and South East Asia... No offense, but the testing is still sporadic and slower than necessary... And without taking appropriate actions following the testing, it is effective only in demonstrating that the numbers are growing...

Quote:
3. If testing wasn't implemented immediately, how do you know there were cases prior to Jan 31, when the travel ban was instituted? Exactly, testing. Although there were C****-** cases in the US in January, as of January 24 the total number of cases in the US was exactly 2 - not quite the case for a national mobilization.


There was some testing prior... But not nearly enough... That was the point... America was aware that the v***s was on its shores and didn't take the appropriate steps... Imagine what an immediate quarantine of those individuals and anyone they had con in contact with until all had been tested could have done to change today's situation?

Reply
Apr 6, 2020 22:34:55   #
Navigator
 
Canuckus Deploracus wrote:
But far fewer than Japan, Korea, and South East Asia... No offense, but the testing is still sporadic and slower than necessary... And without taking appropriate actions following the testing, it is effective only in demonstrating that the numbers are growing...

There was some testing prior... But not nearly enough... That was the point... America was aware that the v***s was on its shores and didn't take the appropriate steps... Imagine what an immediate quarantine of those individuals and anyone they had con in contact with until all had been tested could have done to change today's situation?
But far fewer than Japan, Korea, and South East A... (show quote)


As far as testing is concerned, the US has tested more people than any other country (about 2 million tests to date, compared to about 375 thousand tests by South Korea with the US rate now being 110,000 per day). A more important question might be why was the US response slow (instead of US I could insert England, Italy, France, Spain - in fact, pretty much any country other than China)? Every country in the world, except China, treated this like they treated all other recent epidemics, i.e. Ebola, Swine Flu, Seasonal Flu - none of which combined the extremely rapid spread with a relatively high mortality rate. In other words, every country, except China, used all the expertise they had attained from other epidemics to guide them in their actions against C****-** and all were woefully inadequate in their response - except China. It makes me wonder just exactly what it was that China knew about this particular v***s that caused it to react, unlike every other country in the world, immediately and extremely aggressively, not to inform the rest of the world about what was coming, but to contain the spread internally.

Reply
Apr 6, 2020 22:48:30   #
Canuckus Deploracus Loc: North of the wall
 
Navigator wrote:
As far as testing is concerned, the US has tested more people than any other country (about 2 million tests to date, compared to about 375 thousand tests by South Korea with the US rate now being 110,000 per day). A more important question might be why was the US response slow (instead of US I could insert England, Italy, France, Spain - in fact, pretty much any country other than China)? Every country in the world, except China, treated this like they treated all other recent epidemics, i.e. Ebola, Swine Flu, Seasonal Flu - none of which combined the extremely rapid spread with a relatively high mortality rate. In other words, every country, except China, used all the expertise they had attained from other epidemics to guide them in their actions against C****-** and all were woefully inadequate in their response - except China. It makes me wonder just exactly what it was that China knew about this particular v***s that caused it to react, unlike every other country in the world, immediately and extremely aggressively, not to inform the rest of the world about what was coming, but to contain the spread internally.
As far as testing is concerned, the US has tested ... (show quote)


Korea, Japan, Russia, Taiwan, and numerous other nations were not slow to respond...

Korea and Japan have been able to limit the number of tests needed because the caught it early...

Testing more than another nation is not something to be proud of... Containing the spread is something to be proud of...

There are still people who can't get tested in the US... This is not true for many nations...

Reply
 
 
Apr 7, 2020 02:35:19   #
bggamers Loc: georgia
 
Navigator wrote:
As far as testing is concerned, the US has tested more people than any other country (about 2 million tests to date, compared to about 375 thousand tests by South Korea with the US rate now being 110,000 per day). A more important question might be why was the US response slow (instead of US I could insert England, Italy, France, Spain - in fact, pretty much any country other than China)? Every country in the world, except China, treated this like they treated all other recent epidemics, i.e. Ebola, Swine Flu, Seasonal Flu - none of which combined the extremely rapid spread with a relatively high mortality rate. In other words, every country, except China, used all the expertise they had attained from other epidemics to guide them in their actions against C****-** and all were woefully inadequate in their response - except China. It makes me wonder just exactly what it was that China knew about this particular v***s that caused it to react, unlike every other country in the world, immediately and extremely aggressively, not to inform the rest of the world about what was coming, but to contain the spread internally.
As far as testing is concerned, the US has tested ... (show quote)


Because they didn't say anything till it had gotten out of hand. This was their new year people from all over the world go to china to celebrate with friends and family. By the time they said something it was to late people had already started going back to their jobs in other countries and of course it has a 14-day delay so they infected everyone on the planes and everyone they became close to at the airport taxi driver framilies each of all those are in contact on on on within that 14 days for each person of over 1000 people on just 2 or3 planes and each person contact that's already a p******c and NO ONE EVEN KNEW what was happening in china till it was way to late all who said is they had a v***s they were watching nothing about how bad it was then they start shutting down cities and it started popping up everywhere. All this has put who in the spotlight because they only reported what china wanted and now it is apparent to every country that's paying the price that who can not be trusted.

Reply
Apr 7, 2020 03:00:20   #
Canuckus Deploracus Loc: North of the wall
 
bggamers wrote:
Because they didn't say anything till it had gotten out of hand. This was their new year people from all over the world go to china to celebrate with friends and family. By the time they said something it was to late people had already started going back to their jobs in other countries and of course it has a 14-day delay so they infected everyone on the planes and everyone they became close to at the airport taxi driver framilies each of all those are in contact on on on within that 14 days for each person of over 1000 people on just 2 or3 planes and each person contact that's already a p******c and NO ONE EVEN KNEW what was happening in china till it was way to late all who said is they had a v***s they were watching nothing about how bad it was then they start shutting down cities and it started popping up everywhere. All this has put who in the spotlight because they only reported what china wanted and now it is apparent to every country that's paying the price that who can not be trusted.
Because they didn't say anything till it had gotte... (show quote)


W***n was locked down a few days before new year... Some cases did get out before of course...

But many nations Evacuated citizens after the lockdown...

Reply
Apr 7, 2020 17:22:59   #
Navigator
 
Canuckus Deploracus wrote:
Korea, Japan, Russia, Taiwan, and numerous other nations were not slow to respond...

Korea and Japan have been able to limit the number of tests needed because the caught it early...

Testing more than another nation is not something to be proud of... Containing the spread is something to be proud of...

There are still people who can't get tested in the US... This is not true for many nations...


About containing the spread without resorting to draconian measures as did China: What most people don't realize is that the spread of this v***s is relatively under control in the US. Except for the area I live, the NY, NJ area, in the two months this has been attacking us there are only 15 states where there are more than 100 deaths and only 22 states where there are more than 2500 total cases in the entire state. Granted, between NY and NJ, where I live, there are 2.5 times the number of total cases and twice as many deaths as in the entire country of China, a country with 35 times more people than my area. Yes, where I live it is out of control due to 5,000,000 people riding the subway every day packed in like sardines and local politicians calling early restrictions r****t and encouraging people to get out and socialize.

Reply
Apr 7, 2020 19:43:26   #
Canuckus Deploracus Loc: North of the wall
 
Navigator wrote:
About containing the spread without resorting to draconian measures as did China: What most people don't realize is that the spread of this v***s is relatively under control in the US. Except for the area I live, the NY, NJ area, in the two months this has been attacking us there are only 15 states where there are more than 100 deaths and only 22 states where there are more than 2500 total cases in the entire state. Granted, between NY and NJ, where I live, there are 2.5 times the number of total cases and twice as many deaths as in the entire country of China, a country with 35 times more people than my area. Yes, where I live it is out of control due to 5,000,000 people riding the subway every day packed in like sardines and local politicians calling early restrictions r****t and encouraging people to get out and socialize.
About containing the spread without resorting to d... (show quote)


The measures were definitely draconian...

Effective though...

I shudder to think how bad it may have gotten if we had reacted differently....

Reply
 
 
Apr 7, 2020 19:47:36   #
America 1 Loc: South Miami
 
Navigator wrote:
About containing the spread without resorting to draconian measures as did China: What most people don't realize is that the spread of this v***s is relatively under control in the US. Except for the area I live, the NY, NJ area, in the two months this has been attacking us there are only 15 states where there are more than 100 deaths and only 22 states where there are more than 2500 total cases in the entire state. Granted, between NY and NJ, where I live, there are 2.5 times the number of total cases and twice as many deaths as in the entire country of China, a country with 35 times more people than my area. Yes, where I live it is out of control due to 5,000,000 people riding the subway every day packed in like sardines and local politicians calling early restrictions r****t and encouraging people to get out and socialize.
About containing the spread without resorting to d... (show quote)


"local politicians calling early restrictions r****t and encouraging people to get out and socialize."
May as well called, get out and die.

Reply
Apr 7, 2020 20:44:13   #
Navigator
 
Canuckus Deploracus wrote:
The measures were definitely draconian...

Effective though...

I shudder to think how bad it may have gotten if we had reacted differently....


I guess we will know a lot better come September.

Reply
Apr 7, 2020 20:58:04   #
Canuckus Deploracus Loc: North of the wall
 
Navigator wrote:
I guess we will know a lot better come September.


I think you guys will come out of it earlier Han that... End of May probably.. June latest....

I still worry about a second wave here...


Reply
Apr 8, 2020 16:43:23   #
Navigator
 
Canuckus Deploracus wrote:
I think you guys will come out of it earlier Han that... End of May probably.. June latest....

I still worry about a second wave here...



I was thinking by September we will have more data to determine what strategies worked best for containment, mitigation and treatment. For example, Sweden is totally open with social distancing while Denmark is shut tight. Then we look again the following September (2021) and see if Sweden's resulting herd immunity allows them to be more functional than Denmark in 2021 or will an effective v*****e make it irrelevant. A lot to be learned over the next two years.

Reply
 
 
Apr 11, 2020 12:44:40   #
bggamers Loc: georgia
 
Navigator wrote:
About containing the spread without resorting to draconian measures as did China: What most people don't realize is that the spread of this v***s is relatively under control in the US. Except for the area I live, the NY, NJ area, in the two months this has been attacking us there are only 15 states where there are more than 100 deaths and only 22 states where there are more than 2500 total cases in the entire state. Granted, between NY and NJ, where I live, there are 2.5 times the number of total cases and twice as many deaths as in the entire country of China, a country with 35 times more people than my area. Yes, where I live it is out of control due to 5,000,000 people riding the subway every day packed in like sardines and local politicians calling early restrictions r****t and encouraging people to get out and socialize.
About containing the spread without resorting to d... (show quote)


Arent politicians just wonderful in all their stupidity. Stay safe Navigator

Reply
Apr 11, 2020 12:48:19   #
bggamers Loc: georgia
 
Canuckus Deploracus wrote:
I think you guys will come out of it earlier Han that... End of May probably.. June latest....

I still worry about a second wave here...



what are the numbers for china are you all getting all I can find for china here is 83,000 but its been that for over a month. Read where someone else in china told someone there were so many deaths they were cremating all due to volume of deaths

Reply
Apr 11, 2020 18:57:28   #
Canuckus Deploracus Loc: North of the wall
 
bggamers wrote:
what are the numbers for china are you all getting all I can find for china here is 83,000 but its been that for over a month. Read where someone else in china told someone there were so many deaths they were cremating all due to volume of deaths


Daily increases... Mostly from returnees... Some asymptomatic cases.... There was a small outbreak in Guangzhou.. But they jumped on it...

All Chinese are cremated when they did... Excepting muslims or ethnic groups who have traditionally been buried..

Cuts back on the amount of land used...

Reply
Page <<first <prev 4 of 4
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main
OnePoliticalPlaza.com - Forum
Copyright 2012-2024 IDF International Technologies, Inc.