One Political Plaza - Home of politics
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main
Is Health care a right?
Page <<first <prev 7 of 8 next>
May 29, 2017 09:08:23   #
lindajoy Loc: right here with you....
 
eden wrote:
No, put some American compassion back into the argument. Most other western countries have a hybrid system consisting of a single payer government program that provides the basics, emergency services and palliative hospital care at no out of pocket costs to the patient. Private insurance and private services are available for those that can afford it. Bottom line is that basic care is available that does not put the user at risk of financial ruin because of a catastrophic illness or accident or a pre-existing condition. The public option keeps the private insurers honest. Reduction of paperwork and administrative burdens plus government negotiated prices for medications heavily reduce costs. If small self contained countries like New Zealand can afford this while running a budget surplus so can the USA. Fight this stubborn pig headed irrational propaganda driven fight all you will but rational patriotic pragmatic Americans will find an American solution and our fellow citizens, all of them, will be taken care of...
...Nobody left behind.
No, put some American compassion back into the arg... (show quote)


So in effect you are a supporter of the single payer program which is what this government wants and is g***ming us for anyway..

New Zealand is no where near the size of America.. What works well there does not mean it would here.. Just the variance in population of the USA would make it cost prohibitive...

New Zealand government sponsored insurance comes from the taxes of the its citizens.... So it is not free or a "right".. Anything over 70k is taxed at 33% and up to 14k its 10.5%, in between its average is 27%...As are businesses taxed at a flat rate of 27%...No doubt New Zealand has a budget surplus with its small based populace they are doing very well in their near Socialist format..

Just my humble opinion here but I do believe we are headed to a single payer plan.. The obstacle is most likely from the insurance industry that doesn't want profits impacted.. Nor do they want government rules and regulation..

Reply
May 29, 2017 09:17:51   #
lindajoy Loc: right here with you....
 
Iamdjchrys wrote:
One note...I am on SSDI (Spcial Security Disability Insurance), and have been watching the health care and budget proposals as they trickle down. I have severe PTSD as a result of a brutal assault 17 years ago. I cannot work. .Under the terms of both proposals as they stand today, I would lose SSDI, Medicare (I'm.61) and mental health services. I know that I'm only one person in a country of 330 million or so, but I'm sure there are other disabled citizens with similar stories to tell.


Sorry to read of your incident.. Horrific to say the least...

Why do you feel you would lose benefits ?? We do not yet know what the new plan will cover..From what just came out it's another that will not be passed nor should it be.. But even if the one now was passed how would it impact you?? I assume you have been declared 100% disabled to be on SSDI?? This is why I'm asking .. If too personal please do not reply, that is not my intent..I wanted to apply your situation to the little known in the new plan, which is garbage and needs to be shot down too..

Reply
May 29, 2017 09:29:01   #
JFlorio Loc: Seminole Florida
 
Linddajoy, you just made the point that needs made. No one needs act like chicken little yet. The Republicans are doofuses but they are not stupid enough to throw millions of disabled off benefits. Especially before an e******n. Likewise the lying Democrats would demonize any plan from Republicans even if it doubled benefits.
lindajoy wrote:
Sorry to read of your incident.. Horrific to say the least...

Why do you feel you would lose benefits ?? We do not yet know what the new plan will cover..From what just came out it's another that will not be passed nor should it be.. But even if the one now was passed how would it impact you?? I assume you have been declared 100% disabled to be on SSDI?? This is why I'm asking .. If too personal please do not reply, that is not my intent..I wanted to apply your situation to the little known in the new plan, which is garbage and needs to be shot down too..
Sorry to read of your incident.. Horrific to say t... (show quote)

Reply
 
 
May 29, 2017 09:33:46   #
lindajoy Loc: right here with you....
 
JFlorio wrote:
Don't panic. Nowhere have I seen that your SSDI would be taken away. First off the healthcare bill if ever it gets done will not look like what the House sent the Senate. Don't believe the rhetoric. For instance the Democrats are out their melting down ,saying the new budget cuts a trillion dollars out of Medicaid. It does no such thing. All this budget does is cut the rate of growth of Medicaid. More is actually being spent but not as much as the Democrats would like.


Great reply J, before having gotten here in my reading I asked a few questions as to why she thought she would lose too.. More so to try and give her a little peace in all this garbage coming out about is being stripped from it.. I haven't seen anything either ...

Reply
May 29, 2017 09:46:06   #
lindajoy Loc: right here with you....
 
padremike wrote:
http://cis.org/Cost-Welfare-Immigrant-Native-Households.

I love it that you simple minded progressives believe that "maturity" and being "civilized" is spending your nation and your children into poverty. Thank you for electing Trump!


I like information from Heritage because they have no reason to skew the numbers..
Just another for comparison.. I wonder if Eden even lived in the US given her challenge.. Surely she would know these numbers are over the top??? Anyway:

https://amac.us/illegal-immigration-cost-1/

Also read another that put costs of 57billion up annually if just lookin for totals..

Nothing cheap about immigration costs, eh??? Staggering indeed.. So much do we have spent ourselves into near bankruptcy..While our debt sits at 20trillion...

America First!!!

Reply
May 29, 2017 10:01:01   #
lindajoy Loc: right here with you....
 
eden wrote:
No. Maturity and being civilized means taking care of the health care needs of its citizens who can't afford private health insurance. You know,
old people, vets, the handicapped, poor rural white people....
The e******n of Trump was mostly because of fears by working class white people who are afraid of being marginalized in their own country. (You know..."we want our country back") and is fundamentally a good event because smug liberals need to get off their snooty judgmental high horses and understand that just because you live in a small southern town, still hunt to supplement the table, and keep Grandmas Bible on the mantle does not mean you are a subclass of Americans.
Trump is clueless about healthcare. He just used it as a rallying cry because he thought it would make him lovely with his base. Unfortunately a lot of his base got medical under Obamacare and are leery to switch horses until it is clear that there is a better alternative. Thats why we still mostly have Obamacare because the GOP can't agree on what time of day it is let alone come up with a coherent alternative.
Trumps Presidency will founder if you only listen to conservative pundits and Fox News because you cant run this country like a private investment company that is owned by a slumlord gangster family from New York.
Watch only Fox "News" and you will eventually witness the "et tu Brute" moment.
No. Maturity and being civilized means taking care... (show quote)


Trump may not be perfect but he is for this country whether you believe it or not.. He has also done a very good job given the strong opposition he has faced and will face from the progressive G*******t that have their own agenda in mind...

Plenty Trump doesn't know and will learn in time..he appointed an excellent Supreme Court justice and will likely appoint more.. Against the grain ore liberals he had significantly reduced the number of i******s coming across the borders which will help tremendously in the future costs that will also be saved in healthcare expenditures... The domino effect for such, right along with social programs for the i******s will ultimately help our bottom line payouts we can then use to feminist this staggering 20 trillion dollar debt..

Finally, unlike BO that just put out his Socialistic healthcare Trump has opened it up to discussion by disclosing beforehand the key issues in it.. They have actually read it and put it before open discussion on Criminal Hill and to We the People.. Far more than we got with the previous administration.. You were just told here it is...

What angers me is they tried repealing BO Care for years yet had no alternative already drafted ??? That is simply callous and very poor planning!!!!

Reply
May 29, 2017 10:13:34   #
lindajoy Loc: right here with you....
 
eden wrote:
Yes Obamacare was a disaster for all sorts of reasons but I will give him credit for at least trying when his spineless predecessors on both sides kicked it down the road. His detractors have talked a big talk about replacing it on day one and another big promise bites the dust because they don't have a clue what to replace it with without looking like they support Bolshevik Medical. Sad.


With this I agree, they should have already had rough drafts of replacement ready.. And I'm not talking Ryan's screwed up plan he put forth either..

In reality it should not have been messed with at all, by forcing it on the people, although that is governments answer to everything..

They should have hit the fraudulent enterprise in healthcare..But to do that they would have had to hit those on Criminal Hill responsibile for Medicare/Medicaid-and lost those big slush funds they leave in place for their personal use!!!

Reply
 
 
May 29, 2017 10:14:58   #
lindajoy Loc: right here with you....
 
JFlorio wrote:
O.K.. You admit it is a disaster. I give you kudos for that. He didn't try to improve health care. This is my opinion. I don't believe there is a compassionate bone in his body unless you fit his ideology to a tee. All the ACA was, was a huge t***sfer of wealth. It was also giving an over bloated government control over one sixth of the economy. I don't trust government to have my best interests in mind. Think about it. A government that controls your healthcare controls you. That bothers me. America was founded on rugged individualism. My father and his parents survived the Great Depression. Todays snowflakes would commit suicide, r**t, steal who knows if times got anywhere near that tough. I am Afraid Americans are willing to give up more and more of their freedoms for a promise of security. Whether it be healthcare or that a*********n the Patriot Act.
O.K.. You admit it is a disaster. I give you kudos... (show quote)



Well said!!!! So very true, J!!!

Reply
May 29, 2017 10:48:37   #
lindajoy Loc: right here with you....
 
EmilyStrode wrote:
Preventative healthcare!!!!!! Get it, please. Access to healthcare helps to prevent the need for emergency care and all the indignities and complications that come from waiting for that moment. And such treatment is very expensive. Emergency care when you are near death is a passable pass the buck answer. Diseases and conditions that cause all sorts of complications are not cured in the emergency room: they are treated because they did not have proper care to begin with. "Hey, we let your kidneys fail from lack of access to medical care and now you will need dialysis for the rest of your life but smile we have the machines right here to add hundreds of thousands to the medicare or medicaid deficit. Or just a loss by the hospital."

Are you freaking nuts? Aarrgghh! You guys are unreal in your density to accepting reality. By the time many are forced to the emergency their conditions have either incapacitated them or severely damaged them, meaning more expensive medical procedures or care. If they live! Should they shout "Yiiipppiiiee" at being condemned to such "ignominy."

I will put it down to ignorance or otherwise I would have to say this post and your stance, and Ronald Reagan, are totally inhumane.
Preventative healthcare!!!!!! Get it, please. Acce... (show quote)


I made a single statement relative to why hospitals have to treat everyone coming in..That was because Reagan made it law, not because it's a right or because that hospital is so concerned they are going to voluntarily help us..

I made no statement about ER other than as stated about why hospitals treat..You impugn facts not presented..

Preventative healthcare is what you're actually talking about here..It was not part of your dialogue when I replied..

Likewise I assume you know since health insurance became a routine benefit of employment, amazingly the insurance companies did not often cover preventative exams or tests...Over time, more insurers have begun offering a smattering of preventive coverage... But, to the insured, it was frequently very expensive until the insured reached the plan deductible...Once again, preventive health was on the back burner.. it was typically denied when a person was treating preventable for something..

For the uninsured and limited funds they simply did not treat until as you said it became an emergency.. Under BO care any service rendered was covered and the influx of people who never treated started treatment..An unexpected barrage of people not anticipated and look what happened...Another reason premiums increased over the years..

I think preventive care is well worth paying attention to but even now I suspect it will not be covered just as it wasn't before??? I don't know, not much has been said about it..

Reply
May 29, 2017 11:13:06   #
lindajoy Loc: right here with you....
 
JFlorio wrote:
You must live in a bubble. I worked with at risk families in Ohio that were on the Ohio health care system (Medicaid and local), everything was free to them. You couldn't d**g nine out of ten of these people to the doctor for a checkup. A great majority smoked and drank. Only time they went to the doctor was when they had a catastrophic event. The only people I saw that were diligent were the working poor. They at least took their kid s in regularly. Most of them also smoked and drank. You tell me again how we can grant a human right to someone who doesn't care about their own health. You liberals crack me up. It's easy to say healthcare's a human right and therefore I am a charitable person. Just because people like lindajoy(who is a wonderful person) don't think healthcare is a right granted by the Constitution doesn't mean they don't want people covered. It means we can't find anywhere in the Constitution that specifically grants that right. Does saying healthcare is a human right bring down the cost? Does saying it create more doctors? Will saying healthcare is a right make people take responsibility for their personal choices? Besides saying healthcare is a human right, what's your solution? How would you cover everyone from cradle to grave and pay for it?
You must live in a bubble. I worked with at risk f... (show quote)


Thank You for your compliment and clarification that I did not say I didn't want people covered.. What I did say is the people to which Emily and Eden refer to are and were covered even before BO care came into the mix..

Therefore the people they are speaking of is we, the workers that pay through our taxes anyway..

Forcing us to have a socialist agenda to Insurance is not the answer unless of course as You point out we want to give up our privacy, our right of choice and our ability to not be forced into anything, period.. We loose more of our individual rights with each law they make in the name of terrorism as it is..

Insurance is not a government issue.. Nor do I want a government entity determining my course of treatment on anything..As we saw in BO Care, diagnostic studies suddenly became curtailed and Drs and patients had to go the lessor route of treatment because the insurance people, not Drs said it wasn't needed "yet"... So they pay for that and when not healed or the situation magnified to an emergency then they authorized anything needed..

Follow the money trial and you see the reality of what is really going on.. The insurance industry rules....

Reply
May 29, 2017 11:20:39   #
JFlorio Loc: Seminole Florida
 
Not to give the Republicans a break, they deserve bashing. Obamacare was so unpopular, at first, all they had to do was promise repeal. Most, me included, then thought our health insurance would go back to what we once had. Ah, but Obama and the Democrats knew, create a new entitlement and give millions a benefit they don't have to pay for and there will be hell to pay if you attempt to take it away. Whether it is unsustainable or unfair to the people actually paying for their own and someone else's. Never underestimate the greed of the takers.
lindajoy wrote:
With this I agree, they should have already had rough drafts of replacement ready.. And I'm not talking Ryan's screwed up plan he put forth either..

In reality it should not have been messed with at all, by forcing it on the people, although that is governments answer to everything..

They should have hit the fraudulent enterprise in healthcare..But to do that they would have had to hit those on Criminal Hill responsibile for Medicare/Medicaid-and lost those big slush funds they leave in place for their personal use!!!
With this I agree, they should have already had ro... (show quote)

Reply
 
 
May 29, 2017 11:33:54   #
lindajoy Loc: right here with you....
 
EmilyStrode wrote:
Why are we "obligated" to our children? They don't work. I do and hard, why should I care? My infant shows zero appreciation for what I do, totally takes me for granted. Aarrgghh. I expected way better from you. Obligation is, of course, a state of mind. It comes naturally under a number of circumstances, as with our children. What about to our nation? Most Americans feel that pull. Perhaps not naturally for all but almost as strongly. And to the people next door? Too often it depends. What makes for an "obligation"? The heart, that's it. If you feel that all those Americans, fellow citizens, suffering from various diseases and conditions are of no concern, then you have no obligation. If you feel the same about those unfortunate citizens that are poor, elderly, or disabled, you have no obligation. If you feel that the rich need another tax break at the cost of these people, then, as a Republican, you are obligated to do so.
Why are we "obligated" to our children? ... (show quote)


You are obligated to your children because you chose to have them.. Really, did you need that said???

What about our Nation?? If people took care of themselves and were responsible to their obligation in life there wouldn't even be this discussion going on...

And please don't put supposition in to something I didn't even say.. Those people in the nation that need medical care for wh**ever reason have avenues of treatment already in place.. Medicaid is there if out of work or hospitalized for a catastrophic condition etc .. So are many funding source through charitable organizations or donors.. They are not simply thrown away..

I do volunteer work at the women's shelter, helping young ladies or some in their 30S etc that have children too in filling out forms for child support or court ordered programs they need to apply to etc.. I know first hand their lack of concern for anything other than being sure their food stamp, housing and cash allowance forms are done..They go to the hospital for emergency care and stops right there too.. Girls with babies that get Care through Medicaid benefits don't even take their babies in for follow up Care or immunity shots etc..Too much that could be said here and it really has no relevance to your " right" question..

What I feel about anything is not ruled by a party affiliation as I do not support either, nor is there a party forum other than web the people vs Criminal hilll.. There's your party..

I stand for the right of the people in choice, not government intervention and that is what I have said throughout my posts.. I made no individual comment of People at all...I addressed the topic..

Reply
May 29, 2017 11:57:52   #
lindajoy Loc: right here with you....
 
JFlorio wrote:
Linddajoy, you just made the point that needs made. No one needs act like chicken little yet. The Republicans are doofuses but they are not stupid enough to throw millions of disabled off benefits. Especially before an e******n. Likewise the lying Democrats would demonize any plan from Republicans even if it doubled benefits.


Thank You and yes, the minute something is out for discussion the dems do demonize and in fact lie about what is there..But lololo on how you put it..

No one is going v**e to take away benefits simply because it is e******n cycle and they know we are watching listening and letting them no it's garbage!!

They will change it but just like preexisting it will be opted out for companies if they do wh**ever in qualifiers but they will still an option for people to stay covered.. It won't impact those on Medicaid they still get their coverage or Vets who still get treatment regardless.. Also some of the things reduced are over a10 year period or don't go into effect until 2020, another e******n cycle...

Reply
May 29, 2017 12:11:18   #
lindajoy Loc: right here with you....
 
lindajoy wrote:
Trump may not be perfect but he is for this country whether you believe it or not.. He has also done a very good job given the strong opposition he has faced and will face from the progressive G*******t that have their own agenda in mind...

Plenty Trump doesn't know and will learn in time..he appointed an excellent Supreme Court justice and will likely appoint more.. Against the grain ore liberals he had significantly reduced the number of i******s coming across the borders which will help tremendously in the future costs that will also be saved in healthcare expenditures... The domino effect for such, right along with social programs for the i******s will ultimately help our bottom line payouts we can then use to diminish this staggering 20 trillion dollar debt..

Finally, unlike BO that just put out his Socialistic healthcare Trump has opened it up to discussion by disclosing beforehand the key issues in it.. They have actually read it and put it before open discussion on Criminal Hill and to We the People.. Far more than we got with the previous administration.. You were just told here it is...

What angers me is they tried repealing BO Care for years yet had no alternative already drafted ??? That is simply callous and very poor planning!!!!
Trump may not be perfect but he is for this countr... (show quote)

Reply
May 29, 2017 12:22:29   #
lindajoy Loc: right here with you....
 
JFlorio wrote:
Not to give the Republicans a break, they deserve bashing. Obamacare was so unpopular, at first, all they had to do was promise repeal. Most, me included, then thought our health insurance would go back to what we once had. Ah, but Obama and the Democrats knew, create a new entitlement and give millions a benefit they don't have to pay for and there will be hell to pay if you attempt to take it away. Whether it is unsustainable or unfair to the people actually paying for their own and someone else's. Never underestimate the greed of the takers.
Not to give the Republicans a break, they deserve ... (show quote)


I agree and did already say the republicans slacked off too .... And what they have right now is no better and I hope gets kicked down again!!!

They need to stop letting the insurance companies dictate and do it on their own with then directives to the insurance companies. Problem with that is the insurance industry is a heavy hitter in lobbying control and can just say ok, we won't play at all.. That leaves whoever is manning this to go back to the ins companies and say you won't write this, then you write none and bam that one payer government policy will rule and everyone is screwed over..

Reply
Page <<first <prev 7 of 8 next>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main
OnePoliticalPlaza.com - Forum
Copyright 2012-2024 IDF International Technologies, Inc.