One Political Plaza - Home of politics
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main
If we could add one amendment to the costitution what would it be
Page <prev 2 of 9 next> last>>
Jul 26, 2017 07:45:21   #
pafret Loc: Northeast
 
Rainrider wrote:
As we know a person can't just add an amendment to the constitution. However, we do have the right to submit any that we think would be helpful. SO if we could pick just one thing to work out the details on, what would you pick first?

My self I would hope we could find a way to set term limits for everyone in DC, from judges to the paperboy. Well ok maybe not the paperboy. I also think it would be nice to set congress up to have a ready replacement. With the people holding the power to fire any one in congress that does not hold up their end. Rather than having them vote for their own raises, they should have to go the people that voted them in, and ask for it. If the people say no way, then they don't get it.

Is thre a way we can talk this out with all the grade school kids showing us they have the mind of a 1 grader?
As we know a person can't just add an amendment to... (show quote)



If I can have only one than it is term limits on all Federal elected and appointed positions. Otherwise:

· A balanced budget amendment.
· A redefinition of the General Welfare Clause (the original view was the federal government could not spend money on any topic within the jurisdiction of the states).
· A redefinition of the Commerce Clause (the original view was that Congress was granted a narrow and exclusive power to regulate shipments across state lines–not all the economic activity of the nation).
· A prohibition of using international treaties and law to govern the domestic law of the United States.
· A limitation on using Executive Orders and federal regulations to enact laws (since Congress is supposed to be the exclusive agency to enact laws).
· Imposing term limits on Congress and the Supreme Court.
· Placing an upper limit on federal taxation.
· Requiring the sunset of all existing federal taxes and a super-majority vote to replace them with new, fairer taxes.
Other proposed amendments include measures to protect the right to life and an amendment that would allow two-thirds of the states to negate a federal law.

Reply
Jul 26, 2017 08:02:51   #
Owl32 Loc: ARK
 
This would be a great start, return the Appoinment of Senator's back to the State Legislators of each state.
Where they could be removed at any time by the governor. This was the original method of selection.
Rainrider wrote:
As we know a person can't just add an amendment to the constitution. However, we do have the right to submit any that we think would be helpful. SO if we could pick just one thing to work out the details on, what would you pick first?

My self I would hope we could find a way to set term limits for everyone in DC, from judges to the paperboy. Well ok maybe not the paperboy. I also think it would be nice to set congress up to have a ready replacement. With the people holding the power to fire any one in congress that does not hold up their end. Rather than having them vote for their own raises, they should have to go the people that voted them in, and ask for it. If the people say no way, then they don't get it.

Is thre a way we can talk this out with all the grade school kids showing us they have the mind of a 1 grader?
As we know a person can't just add an amendment to... (show quote)

Reply
Jul 26, 2017 08:36:43   #
roy
 
Owl32 wrote:
This would be a great start, return the Appoinment of Senator's back to the State Legislators of each state.
Where they could be removed at any time by the governor. This was the original method of selection.


How about making it a hanging offense for accepting any money or gifts from lobbiest,

Reply
 
 
Jul 26, 2017 08:48:52   #
Dewey Dee
 
Term limits on congress two terms that's it, and payed for the time spent in session.
That all laws and programs that apply to citizens also apply to members of Congress.
No private healthcare, no retirement for life.
That the Speaker of the house and the sergeant of arms to reprimand anyone that breaks a law, or who does not perform their duties.
The President terms be set to 6 years.

I am in agreement with most all of you on here. We the people should have some input on what their representatives are doing and saying.

Reply
Jul 26, 2017 08:54:37   #
Super Dave Loc: Realville, USA
 
NUKE wrote:
There are several critical amendments that would instantly transform America:
1) Fair Tax amendment eliminating the IRS and replacing the current production tax system with a consumption tax system with point of sale electronic distribution of tax revenue.
2) Executive Branch elections performed completely by Congress with no confidence vote taken upon demand.
3) Elimination of US Mint and conversion of US Monetary system to electronic only.


Congress installing POTUS? Too much power to gubmit.

Fair tax will need an IRS. The amendment would have to outlaw most forms of taxation.

Electronic money as a sole means would be a disaster.

Reply
Jul 26, 2017 08:56:14   #
JFlorio Loc: Seminole Florida
 
I know this suggestion is out there. I would like taxes used to run the Federal Government to be paid by all. From the paperboy to the congressman.
When we go to war, build infrastructure, whatever, everyone should have some skin in the game.
Rainrider wrote:
As we know a person can't just add an amendment to the constitution. However, we do have the right to submit any that we think would be helpful. SO if we could pick just one thing to work out the details on, what would you pick first?

My self I would hope we could find a way to set term limits for everyone in DC, from judges to the paperboy. Well ok maybe not the paperboy. I also think it would be nice to set congress up to have a ready replacement. With the people holding the power to fire any one in congress that does not hold up their end. Rather than having them vote for their own raises, they should have to go the people that voted them in, and ask for it. If the people say no way, then they don't get it.

Is thre a way we can talk this out with all the grade school kids showing us they have the mind of a 1 grader?
As we know a person can't just add an amendment to... (show quote)

Reply
Jul 26, 2017 08:56:51   #
Super Dave Loc: Realville, USA
 
roy wrote:
How about making it a hanging offense for accepting any money or gifts from lobbiest,


Overkill.

If you invited a congressman into your home for a meal he could be killed.

Reply
 
 
Jul 26, 2017 09:04:05   #
roy
 
Super Dave wrote:
Overkill.

If you invited a congressman into your home for a meal he could be killed.


One would never come to my home,i dont have several million dollars

Reply
Jul 26, 2017 09:07:12   #
Super Dave Loc: Realville, USA
 
roy wrote:
One would never come to my home,i dont have several million dollars

LOL

Reply
Jul 26, 2017 09:40:51   #
Michael Rich Loc: Lapine Oregon
 
Mandatory public audit of "OUR" money every two years...

Reply
Jul 26, 2017 10:00:30   #
Super Dave Loc: Realville, USA
 
byronglimish wrote:
Mandatory public audit of "OUR" money every two years...


At least

Reply
 
 
Jul 26, 2017 12:35:39   #
Docadhoc Loc: Elsewhere
 
Rainrider wrote:
If the people have the right to fire them, is that not enough? Or do you think the people should be able to fire them, and then bring them up on changes? We need to work every thing into one Amendment, so we must make it clear. Yes I am going to write one up, and it will be sent out to get as many people to sign as we can.


Lose the idea of.the people directly firing anyone. That is what elections are for. If you.think a national vote can be called for every politician that torqued off enough people, we'd do nothing but vote to fire them daily. It takes too long and is too costly.

Develope language that makes dismissal from office automatic.

Perhaps a clear cut job description for every office including what is not allowed would be a better approach. It seems to me that these jobs have hazy lines that make it too easy to transgress. It has allowed these positions to morph into a self sustaining machine that functions with almost no limitations.

Reply
Jul 26, 2017 12:39:39   #
Docadhoc Loc: Elsewhere
 
Super Dave wrote:
Those are all excellent common-sense suggestions. But excepting of term limits for SCOTUS none of them are really enforceable.


Once they become an amendment they become enforceable. Setting the parameters is the tough part.

Reply
Jul 26, 2017 15:41:08   #
Super Dave Loc: Realville, USA
 
Docadhoc wrote:
Once they become an amendment they become enforceable. Setting the parameters is the tough part.


Subjective parameters don't work.

It would be like an Amendment against 'bad legislation'. Nice idea, but undoable.

Reply
Jul 26, 2017 16:11:13   #
Docadhoc Loc: Elsewhere
 
Super Dave wrote:
Subjective parameters don't work.

It would be like an Amendment against 'bad legislation'. Nice idea, but undoable.


Difficult, yes. Undoable, not sure. It would be worth a shot. If enough people could agree on the parameters, but that is the hurdle. Maybe not possible but worth the try.

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 9 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main
OnePoliticalPlaza.com - Forum
Copyright 2012-2024 IDF International Technologies, Inc.