permafrost wrote:
Critic,
My point has nothing to do with what the actual form our political system is..
it is a republic.. a democratic republic..
No, it is not a “democratic republic”, not even sure if such a form of government even exists. Our form of government is a republic.. a federated republic. I challenge you to find me a quote, any quote, from any one of the framers stating that the American form of government they crafted was/is to be called a “democratic republic”. Each and every state is a republic unto themselves, each granting the “federal” government limited powers, while all other powers were/are retained by each state, or the people; 9th & 10th amendments. The individual states form a confederation of republics bound by the constitution. (E pluribus unum) Out of many, one. (the motto of the US).
Quote:
our founding fathers were scared that an uneducated majority was as big a risk as the very rich and kings of Europe..
Actually, what they were afraid of was “the excesses of democracy” - research the term. Also look into, “Instructions of the Inhabitants of Malden, Massachusetts to their Representatives in Congress" on May 27, 1776. Then move on to the “Essex Result”. (Report of the 1778 Convention of the towns of Essex County, Massachusetts) also (1776 Pittsfield Resolution) and (The Federalist, particularly numbers 17, 32, 33 and 83 by Hamilton and numbers 39, 40, 41 and 45 by Madison)
Quote:
My question is why a sliver of the right cares about terminology so much..
I don’t know why you refer to it as a sliver, I think you would be surprised at the amount of people that care. And, it’s because of accuracy of terminology. It matters that future generations understand and comprehend their form of government, so that future generations of ignorant progressives are not able to hoodwink the uninformed.
Quote:
In our world today.. the United States is called a Democracy every day, by all sorts of government and media types..
You’re absolutely correct, they do, and both parties are to blame, which is why it is important to correct the ignorant masses. Just because it is repeated so often, doesn’t mean it is correct, or the right thing to be doing.
Quote:
It seems to be not even an issue in the world, only general accepted terms... I do not care, why should anyone..
Perhaps it is not an issue to the world, but I don’t particularly care what the rest of the world calls our form of government, their opinions mean absolutely nothing. Citizens of this country should care, especially anyone who takes an oath to defend this country and its ideals.
Quote:
While it is important to know the text book definition of our type of government,
If you think it important to know the definition of our
form of government, then why wouldn’t you invest the time to learn it yourself?
Quote:
I see no point at all in insisting the term "Democracy" be dropped when defining our nation..
I’ll agree to that when you can show me where in our founding documents, the word
democracy is used to define our form of government. In order for the word to be dropped from somewhere, it must actually exist somewhere.
Quote:
Ryan
The United States is "the oldest democracy" in the world.
— Paul Ryan on Sunday, June 26th, 2016 in a TV interview
And do you recall that he was lambasted for making such an ignorant statement? Apparently he never read anything about Ancient Greece.