AuntiE, as you PMed me with this post from Jeffery T. Brown, here is my reply. I've also included a post by David M. Schell.
While I can understand Mr Brown's point of view, his painting all liberals with the same brush totally goes against my understanding of the teachings of Christ. Mr. Brown is NOT what I would want as a teacher of Christianity as his "theology" appears to be completely black and white, with NO room for in between. To imply that all liberals are atheistic denies the fact that even the Jews of the time declared Christ to be a blasphemer and of satan.
Remember, too, that Israel was a theocracy, even though it was under Roman domination. The Romans allowed the Israelites to continue worshipping God as they had before the Romans conquered the country. As such, we must be careful not to confuse the religious/state practices of ancient Israel with the separation of religion and state that we have in the U.S.
Think about it for a moment. What would our country be like if Christianity were to become the "state religion?" How long would it take before we had arguments over which religion should be dominant, Protestant, Roman Catholic, or Eastern Orthodox? Let's say we decided on Protestantism, then, how long before we were arguing whether or not the dominant denomination should be Methodist, Presbyterianism, Southern Baptist, LDS, or Church of Christ? As intense as our disagreements are over politics, can you imagine how bad they'd be if we were determining the salvation of the souls of our citizenry? Now, I suppose I could get really theological and go off and quote scripture that would support my comments, but, for the reason that the battery on my iPad is at 10% and the charger is in the back bedroom, I'll not.
I will say that Mr Brown's comments are very troubling to me in that he doesn't allow for the compassion that Christ shows toward those of differing beliefs. In fact, the only times He does show His temper is when He is talking to the Pharisees (those who thought themselves better and more knowledgable of God's wants and wishes, yet failed miserably, themselves, in their thoughts and actions toward their living and speaking about God) and when He throws the money changers out of His Father's House. Mr Brown sounds very much like a Pharisee in his declarations about liberals. To him, it's his way or no way. Plus, he has the audacity to allude to the idea that he knows God's thoughts and wants. I wonder if it ever occurred to him that maybe, he's in error in his understanding of what the Bible teaches about showing our faith by loving our neighbors as ourselves. I've not ever run across anything that says to discriminate against those of differing beliefs. Along that vein, I believe the Bible says we're to leaving the judging of others to God.
Our Founding Fathers left religion out of the Constitution, except to state there would be NO State religion. They did it because 1: they wanted no one to be compelled to support a religion they didn't believe in, and 2: they wanted everyone to be free to practice the religion of their choice or not to practice any religion; if they so chose. To say that this is a "Christian nation" is not true, based on the Constitution. Look it up. Is Christianity declared to be our "state religion?" Is any religion declared to be our " state religion?" Many of our Founding Fathers were Christian and deists, as were many of the colonists. But, its a historical fact that the majority of the colonists didn't attend any church on a regular basis. Their belief systems were based on their religious convictions, and that the majority were Christian, is a good thing. But, nowhere in the Constitution is it stated as such and nowhere is it made a requirement for citizenship or to hold elected office. That there are Christians, Jews, Buddhists, Hindus, Muslims, and "un-declared" in Congress, today, testifies to the fact that we run our government with a blind eye toward one's religious convictions. Did you know that there are 7 L**T members in the present Congress. WOW!!! (As a side note, how many of you conservatives have heard of the Log Cabin Republicans?)
Now, if any of you want to know, I am a Christian. I'm proud to declare myself a Christian, if the subject comes up; as in this case. But, I'm NOT one to declare that someone else, who declares himself or herself a Christian, not to be one, simply because we are of different political opinions. For someone else (Mr Brown) to make that insinuation, is to me, personally, very insulting and very non-Christian in its extremely judgmental and politically motivated postulation.
It saddens me, too, that so many people think that the exclusivity of Mr Brown's article is how Christians should believe. If I were looking to choose if I'd want to become a Christian, and read this opinion of Mr Brown's, I'd decide, right then and there, that his religion isn't the one for me.
Remember, becoming and/or remaining a Christian IS a choice that we all make. It's affected by how others, who declare themselves to be Christians, act and speak, when with others of the world. If you want to be a good ambassador of your faith, you need to treat others as you'd want to be treated. (Now, where have I heard that before?)
BELOW IS THE ARTICLE BY MR. SCHELL
Unacceptable: What its like to be a Liberal Christian in a Sea of Conservativism
Posted on July 23, 2014 by David M Schell
People think I moved left because I wanted to compromise with the world, because I wanted to fit in better.
People think I moved left because I was deceived by the devil.
People think I moved left because Ive been reading the Bible without the help of the Holy Spirit.
People think I moved left because I just stopped reading the Bible.
I accidentally go to conservative churches sometimes and find books by Ken Ham that say Ive c*********d with the world, the devil, wh**ever.
My dad sees me as a disappointment and is glad Im still alive. He doesnt say it, but Im pretty sure he thinks that if I died today Id be in hell. He holds out hope that God will show me the light because Im still alive.
My Grandma calls me and says shes heard rumors that I dont believe in the Bible anymore.
My aunt sends me a Facebook message that her kids, my very young cousins, are praying for me. Theyre worried about my soul.
When my conservative Christian friends and family ask me questions, its not to find out why I believe what I believe. Its to fix me or help me realize that Ive gone off the rails and am wrong.
Other folks have very real concerns that because I dont share their view of the atonement, Im not a real Christian.
Ive gotten tired of arguing about stuff, because its always the same argument. It may be new to you, but Ive had it a hundred times and it always ends the same sad way. Seriously, lets pass on it. Its not worth it.
No, seriously. Its not.
I hear the same tired arguments and Bible verses over and over again. I know them all, I promise. And I have responses to all of them, but you probably wont like or agree with my responses, so can we please pass on the high-stakes debate? Id be happy to have a conversation with you about why I believe what I believe if youre curious, but I dont want to fight about it.
Ive fought enough already.
The churches I go to are small, because evangelicalism and rock bands and the feeling that theres something real going on attract more people my age than silence and liturgy and ambiguity.
People think that because I dont think that the Bibles inerrancy is a fundamental doctrine, Im not a Christian, or at least Im on the road toward apostasy. Were Christians, not Biblians.
When I visit big churches, I consider myself lucky to get a phone call that might be important to get me out of a worship service with stifling, repetitive, boring, and theologically dumb (at best) songs.
When I visit big churches, Im always the compromiser the pastors talking about.
When I visit big churches, things that inspire other peoples faith scare me to death and make me wonder why Im in this whole Christianity thing anyway.
My dad warns me that Im deceiving people and reminds me that Gods going to have a stricter judgment for me.
Sometimes I try to keep my political posts down so as not to aggravate my conservative friends who share clips about why Obama is the anti-Christ every five minutes. I promise you guys, you only have to put up with him for two more years. Plus, Im not a big fan anyway but my reasons have nothing to do with Obamacare, except that I think it didnt go far enough.
When I comment on pro-Israel posts to mention that Gaza has a higher death count, everybody thinks I wish Gaza would just bomb Israel off the map, or that I have absolutely no idea whats going on, or that I dont believe in the Bible, or that Im just deceived by the devil. Its kind of a theme.
I see posts from Christians that are against i*****l i*********n and I get so confused how Christians who are supposed to love our neighbors can stand at the border and tell little children from war-torn countries that Jesus wants them to go away.
I go to a church in a denomination that other churches are leaving because they cant stand the idea of being in the same denomination as churches that are allowed to perform same-sex marriage. The PCUSA has space for both sides, and while the liberal churches are okay with worshipping alongside those who disagree, the conservative churches have no space for that sort of disagreement about fundamental issues like the resurrection.
Oh wait, that was about gay marriage. Never mind. Like I said, it makes me sad.
I mention that Im in favor of marriage e******y and people think Im not a Christian.
I mention that I attend a Presbyterian church and everyone wonders how I can go to a church whose denomination allows (not supports) same-sex marriage.
Friends and family members who once respected me and had high hopes for my future are now praying for my eternal salvation.
I have space for my conservative brothers and sisters in Christ, but far too often for my happiness, they dont have space for me.
I didnt shift left because it made my life easier. I shifted left because I went to college and learned that the world doesnt work in the simple logical way that conservative talk-show hosts and evangelical / fundamentalist pastors think it does. Its complicated. Rush Limbaughs logic is missing large chunks of data that anyone whod taken Sociology 101 would know.
Shifting left has made my life harder. My life would be easier if I suddenly realized that Rush Limbaugh and Glenn Beck were right about Jesus, and John Dominic Crossan wasnt.
I cant even imagine how many of my friends and relatives would breathe a sigh of relief if I threw away everything Ive learned and suddenly realized that being gay is a sin, or that the Bible was absolutely true about literally everything it said and had no disagreements within it (a relatively modern view).
But that aint how I was raised.
I was raised to stand for t***h and justice even if you stand alone, and even if you look like a fool while youre doing it.
I was raised to speak up when the world around me is cheering for injustice and evil. I was raised to disagree. I was raised to misbehave and stand against the current.
Veggietales taught me to stand up for what I believe in.
Patch the Pirate taught me to do right until the stars fall down.
I even wrote a little song about how you gotta to dare to be different that was so bad that nobody but Andrew will ever hear it. Ever.
But I also do it because it helps. I do it because every now and then, I get a message from someone saying that they read my blog all the time and feel encouraged and not-alone. I do it because sometimes I get messages saying Hey, I read your blog and it got me thinking.
I do it because I know people whove been beaten over the head with the Bible and dont like God very much right now, and I want to give them hope that maybe they can be wh**ever they are and God will still love them and maybe they can still be Christians.
I do it because sometimes Im one of those people.
I do it because I want people who are on the margins of Christianity and think the whole thing might just be nuts to know that things they think is crazy, I think are crazy too, and if I can be a Christian, maybe they can too.
One thing more.
I dont have it nearly as hard as my L**T brothers and sisters, or as hard as my Palestinian brothers and sisters, or my immigrant brothers and sisters, or my brothers and sisters anywhere who also feel the ire of conservative Christianity. So I speak up for them.
Because I believe its the right thing to do.
###########
FYI- before you go off the deep-end over his comments about gays/LBGT, Mr Schell isn't gay. He's married to a woman and has kids. Alabuck
AuntiE, as you PMed me with this post from Jeffer... (
show quote)