One Political Plaza - Home of politics
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main
Binding allegiance to The Donald
Page 1 of 11 next> last>>
Sep 28, 2023 13:43:01   #
slatten49 Loc: Lake Whitney, Texas
 
(From a much more talented writer than I, and worthy of being read in its entirety.)

During a town hall earlier this year, Donald Trump acted as expected. He used the phrase “whack job” to describe E. Jean Carroll, who was awarded $5 million in damages because a jury unanimously concluded that Trump had sexually abused and defamed her. His statement elicited applause and laughter from the mostly pro-Trump crowd. He also described the J****** 6 i**********n as a “beautiful day” and declared that, if reelected president in 2024, he would pardon a “large portion” of the r****rs. Those statements, too, brought applause from the raucous audience.

There was more. Trump called the black police officer who had shot and k**led one of the r****rs storming the Capitol a “thug,” falsely claiming that the officer had bragged about the incident. Trump defended taking top-secret documents to his Mar-a-Lago estate. He wouldn’t say whether he hoped that Ukraine would win the war against Russia. And he spewed lie after lie after lie about the 2020 e******n and virtually every other topic that came up.

As the townhall host said of Trump, summing up the night, “He declared war on the t***h, and I’m not sure that he didn’t win.”

The day after the town hall, a person in the talk-radio world was asked how his listeners had responded. “One hundred percent approval of Trump’s performance,” this individual, who requested anonymity in order to speak candidly, told me. “I even tried to get people to call me who didn’t think he did well, but no luck. And I received a number of calls saying they had been either leaning towards [Ron] DeSantis or were firmly in his camp, and they said they have now decided to fully support Trump, based on the town hall.”

The question I’ve been asked more than any other during the Trump era is how Trump supporters—including tens of millions of evangelical Christians and Republicans who have long viewed themselves as champions of “family values” and “law and order”—justify their enthusiastic support for the former president. How do they rationalize their embrace of a man whose ethical t***sgressions and moral depravity so far exceed that of Bill Clinton, whom many of them attacked in the 1990s on moral grounds?

I’m intentional in trying to better understand the mind of Trump supporters. I read their articles and social-media posts, listen to their interviews, and track the findings of focus groups. I engage them in conversation and reply to their emails, less to debate than to listen. I think I’ve come to understand their perspective, even though I profoundly disagree with it.

Trump supporters can’t simply be dismissed as “a basket of deplorables.” Many are dev**ed parents and spouses, loyal friends and good neighbors, willing to reach out a hand to those in need. I can’t deny what I have seen with my own eyes; I can’t let my own aversion to Trump turn his supporters into caricatures. At the same time, they have aligned themselves with a malignant figure whose corruptions are undisguised. How can these things fit together?

Part of the explanation can be found in the realm of human psychology. None of us live comfortably with cognitive dissonance, the mental stress that results when people’s beliefs and actions come into direct contradiction with one another. This disharmony causes distress, agitation, and self-loathing. It can’t be sustained; something has to give.

The human mind creates defense mechanisms to eliminate such negative feelings: avoiding or ignoring the dissonance, undermining evidence of the dissonance, belittling its importance. What we human beings don’t do nearly enough is change our behavior so that it aligns with values that are estimable and ennobling.

If a person is on a diet and spends late nights eating snacks, they may tell themselves that they’ll work out the next day to burn off the extra calories. A smoker may justify her habit by reassuring herself that even though smoking can cause cancer, she knows people who have smoked and lived long, healthy lives. A man who c***ts on his spouse may justify his actions by saying that the marriage was irretrievably broken, that he felt unloved by his wife, that he hasn’t felt happy for many years and she’s to blame.

“By coming up with these rationalizations, people are able to preserve the impression that their behaviors and attitudes are consistent,” Benjamin Le, a psychology professor of Haverford College, has written.

Which brings me back to supporters of Donald Trump. It’s a challenge for many of them, especially those who identify as people of Faith, to reconcile what they claim to value—integrity, honor, t***hfulness, decency, compassion—with the fact that they support a misogynist who has c***ted on his wives and sexually abused women; threatened judges, prosecutors, and e******n officials; used hundreds of millions of dollars in military assistance to pressure a foreign leader to dig up dirt on his political opponent; catalyzed a violent i**********n and engaged in a multipart conspiracy to overturn the lawful results of the 2020 p**********l e******n; dined with w***e s*********ts and anti-Semites; c***ted on his taxes; lied pathologically; routinely used cruel and dehumanizing rhetoric; and promoted political violence.

So what are the psychological defense mechanisms Trump supporters employ to relieve feelings of dissonance, shame, and embarrassment?

First, Trump supporters deny the worst things he has done. Jury verdicts against him are always unfair; impeachments are unjust partisan acts. Investigations of him that have found wrongdoing, all of them, are “witch hunts.” That is true in perpetuity. So wh**ever Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis and Special Counsel Jack Smith find, wh**ever indictments they may bring, the charges are by definition unwarranted. Trump is always the victim of persecution. “I think I have been violated as badly as anybody that's ever walked,” he recently said.

Trump is not perfect, most of his supporters will concede; he may be rough around the edges—a “bull in a China shop,” in the words of one friend of mine; a “wrecking ball,” in the words of another—and a man who does some unsavory things. But all of that, and far more than that, is acceptable because he is a “fighter” for their cause, which they are convinced is just, true, and right. His conduct may not always be ideal, and you may not want your son to model his life after Donald Trump’s. But more than any other Republican politician, he understands the viciousness of his opponents and will respond in kind. Trump will bring an AR-15 to a cultural knife fight, and his supporters find that to be anywhere from tolerable to thrilling.

Second, Trump supporters catastrophize the threats of the left. It’s one thing to believe, as some of us do, that the progressive movement includes dangerous, illiberal elements that need to be opposed. But that is quite different from believing that if Democrats gain or maintain power, calamity follows and America as we know it dies.

What we’re talking about isn’t just fear; it’s a sense of desperation and impending doom. Trump supporters feel that the political right has lost on every front over the past several decades, even though that’s clearly not the case. Since 1990, for example, the right has gained significantly more power in the courts, in Congress, and in the media—hardly unimportant institutions. Roe v. Wade was overturned after a half century, securing one of the great goals of the American right, and no land has afforded more religious-liberty protections to Christians than the United States today. Yet none of these victories offers much reassurance to people addicted to “doomscrolling,” searching social media for upsetting news.

Moreover, the unwillingness of others to share in their despair—the unwillingness to fight as if our lives depended on the outcome of this or that political e******n—is viewed as a sign of weakness. All of this is reinforced by a media ecosystem that is constantly promoting narratives that elicit feelings of fright, grievance, agitation, and rage. Those outlets take their cue from Trump, who last year said Democrats are responsible for “blood, death, and suffering on a scale once unthinkable.” He added, “Our country is going to hell.”

If the threat is truly existential, then it justifies—indeed, it demands—that patriotic Americans stand with Trump, regardless of his ethical t***sgressions. To offer anything less than full support would be a betrayal of our nation. A significant number of Trump supporters see themselves as embattled but heroic figures, involved in a great drama, standing against the demise of almost everything they cherish.

But this disposition comes with a price. Perfect love may cast out fear, as the New Testament says, but the converse is also true. As Aldous Huxley wrote, “Fear casts out love. And not only love. Fear also casts out intelligence, casts out goodness, casts out all thought of beauty and t***h.”

Third, Trump and his supporters are frantically trying to portray President Joe Biden as more corrupt than his predecessor. If Trump is an innocent man forever being framed, Biden is the head of a “crime family,” according to Trump, who labeled a set of unproven allegations against Biden as “Watergate times 10.”

The charge against Biden is led by the Republican chair of the House Committee on Oversight and Accountability, James Comer, who declared himself a “Trump man” shortly after the J****** 6 assault on the Capitol.

Comer’s target isn’t simply H****r B***n, the president’s son, who has engaged in problematic business dealings. The U.S. attorney in Delaware, David C. Weiss, will soon decide whether H****r B***n should be prosecuted for crimes related to taxes and a gun purchase. (The investigation into H****r B***n began in 2018 and initially centered on his finances related to overseas business ties and consulting work, but later shifted in focus.)

However, Republicans are after the president himself, not his son, and so far, despite months of investigation, they have yet to uncover incriminating material about him. That doesn’t stop Republicans from accusing President Biden of wrongdoing. The Trump acolyte Charlie Kirk has admitted that “one of the reasons why Joe Biden is tough to beat is because he’s tough to h**e.” Portraying Biden as unscrupulous is one way to change that impression, even if the specific charges made against him are false. If Republicans are able to get at least a draw between Biden and Trump on personal and public morality, they’ll take it.

A fourth justification that supporters of Donald Trump have constructed is that his presidency was an unqualified success, that Trump did practically everything right. There is plenty of evidence to the contrary: failing to build the wall or to get Mexico to pay for it, to reduce i*****l i*********n, to handle the c****av***s p******c, to close the trade gap, to narrow the deficit or, pre-p******c, substantially grow the economy and real wages. The Trump presidency, however, did witness health-care costs and drug prices increasing; income ine******y growing; a******ns rising after a three-decade decline; homicides spiking, including the largest single-year increase in murders in more than a century; the erosion of U.S. credibility worldwide; a posture of petty feuding with allies and abject capitulation to dictators; and a U.S.-Taliban agreement and subsequent announcement that the American military would withdraw, which had a devastating effect on the Afghan military’s morale and was a “catalyst” for its collapse, according to a May 2022 interim report by the Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction. Yet all of these things, and more, are either ignored or explained away.

Let’s assume that Trump supporters believe, contrary to the facts, that every bad thing that happened on Trump’s watch was not because of his policies but in spite of them. Even then, they’re conceding how easily thwarted Trump was and how, in many cases, he was ineffective.

A fair-minded assessment would conclude that on Trump’s watch, some things got better and some things got worse, some of which he’s responsible for and some of which he’s not. But no one can reasonably make the case that America was markedly better or stronger during the Trump presidency than under either his predecessor or his successor. And certainly America under Bill Clinton, reviled by many on the right, prospered in ways that far exceed anything we saw under Trump. But back then, unlike now, we were told that character mattered.

The psychological phenomenon I’ve described in this essay isn’t exclusive to members of one party or to politics. We all live in ways that are at odds with our deepest beliefs. We all rationalize our shortcomings; we all engage in forms of denial. Each of us has blind spots, seeing confirmation bias in others but not in ourselves. But there are varying degrees of self-deception, different lengths to which we go to justify our decisions. What is so striking is just how much Trump demanded of his supporters. He has gone to the darkest places, and they have followed him every step of the way.

So, will anything invalidate the rationalizations of Donald Trump supporters? Or do his violations bind them to him more tightly than ever? For almost eight years, the answer has been the latter. Trump’s sensibilities have become theirs; they have thoroughly internalized his will-to-power ethic. An extraordinary psychological and moral accommodation has occurred.

If a decade ago you had told Trump supporters that this is the kind of man they would defend, that this is what they would become, most of them would have been horrified.

At this stage, though, for Trump supporters to call him out would be to call out themselves, and that’s too painful for too many people. The greater the ethical compromises we make, the fiercer our justifications become—and the angrier and more frustrated we get at those who won’t go along for the ride.

If most Republicans finally do break with Trump—and at this point, very little evidence suggests they will—it won’t be because of any road-to-Damascus revelation. It will be done respectfully, even reverentially, not because they have rejected his style of politics, but because they sense that his time has come and gone. And if Trump is dethroned as the leader of the Republican Party, whoever succeeds him will have modeled themselves after him. Trumpism will outlive Trump. It’s the cost of the lies we sometimes tell ourselves.

Reply
Sep 28, 2023 13:56:43   #
Coos Bay Tom Loc: coos bay oregon
 
I have often heard those who have v**ed for him say-- I despise the man but really like his policies --- Guess they can overlook every bad thing he has done .

Reply
Sep 28, 2023 13:58:06   #
proud republican Loc: RED CALIFORNIA
 
It's interesting how you guys on the left can't stop talking or thinking about FORMER President.. Unbelievable how he still lives in your brains rent free...Seriously guys you need mental help with all due respect..

Reply
 
 
Sep 28, 2023 14:00:14   #
Coos Bay Tom Loc: coos bay oregon
 
proud republican wrote:
It's interesting how you guys on the left can't stop talking or thinking about FORMER President.. Unbelievable how he still lives in your brains rent free...Seriously guys you need mental help with all due respect..
We are not the ones who need help ----

Reply
Sep 28, 2023 14:04:04   #
proud republican Loc: RED CALIFORNIA
 
Coos Bay Tom wrote:
We are not the ones who need help ----


With all due respect, YES, you do.....

Reply
Sep 28, 2023 14:14:09   #
American Vet
 
Sadly, you lied. It wasn’t worth reading.

FJB has done more damage to America than any previous president. <and James Earl Carter breathes a sigh of relief >.

Reply
Sep 28, 2023 14:25:28   #
Michael Roy Loc: North of Amarillo
 
American Vet wrote:
Sadly, you lied. It wasn’t worth reading.

FJB has done more damage to America than any previous president. <and James Earl Carter breathes a sigh of relief >.


The first paragraph was bs and then it just went on and on and on and on.

Reply
 
 
Sep 28, 2023 14:27:10   #
Michael Roy Loc: North of Amarillo
 
Michael Roy wrote:
The first paragraph was bs and then it just went on and on and on and on.


It doesn’t take that much ink to write t***h.

Reply
Sep 28, 2023 14:41:50   #
Liberty Tree
 
Coos Bay Tom wrote:
We are not the ones who need help ----


America needs help from people like you.

Reply
Sep 28, 2023 14:43:24   #
Liberty Tree
 
Coos Bay Tom wrote:
I have often heard those who have v**ed for him say-- I despise the man but really like his policies --- Guess they can overlook every bad thing he has done .


As you overlook what Biden has done and is doing to America.

Reply
Sep 28, 2023 14:56:13   #
martsiva
 
Coos Bay Tom wrote:
We are not the ones who need help ----


Anyone who supports Biden and all the damage he`s done to this country needs help!! From your reply that must mean you!!

Reply
 
 
Sep 28, 2023 15:03:48   #
Wolf counselor Loc: Heart of Texas
 
Awe don't cry little Goober



Reply
Sep 28, 2023 15:04:42   #
Rose42
 
The author misses the boat on numerous things but I’ll just mention one and its not a defense of Trump or his behavior

As far as Christians go, if they were going to v**e for someone who never did anything wrong then they’d never v**e. There is no grading system for sinning. Biden would never have gotten their v**e either

This country is in a dangerous situation. For all the complaining about trump, we have an inept, stumbing bumbling White House occupant who has fewer leadership sk**ls than a turnip yet inexplicably is running again and people accept it. Think about that.

Reply
Sep 28, 2023 16:14:53   #
Coos Bay Tom Loc: coos bay oregon
 
proud republican wrote:
With all due respect, YES, you do.....


Thanks for offering then--being as I need to cook the family's meals now I might ask for some culinary advice . You are kind of stubborn but deep down you have a heart of gold . I admire you for that .

Reply
Sep 28, 2023 16:16:15   #
Coos Bay Tom Loc: coos bay oregon
 
martsiva wrote:
Anyone who supports Biden and all the damage he`s done to this country needs help!! From your reply that must mean you!!


Yep the national unemployment rate is down to 3.5%-lord have mercy .

Reply
Page 1 of 11 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main
OnePoliticalPlaza.com - Forum
Copyright 2012-2024 IDF International Technologies, Inc.