Augustus Greatorex wrote:
A man's religion is his thoughts, words, and deeds.
His spirituality is his state of being.
A man's religion is observable. Do his words match his actions? If they do not, then his religion is other than he has claimed.
A man's spirituality is unobservable, and as such neither he, nor we, can know it.
The claim of being spiritual is a claim of the unprovable.
I claim no "specific" religion, yet my actions more often than "not" reflect my belief in a greater power. If I state I belong to no religion, but my actions reflect some homage to a higher power, does that not reflect spirituality?
State of being...I think it is observable.....why else would doctors say the patient is in a comatose or vegetative state or that the individual was in a state of euphoria? They have developed criteria to affirm such a state, because certain criteria can be discerned. So, if, as you claim, and I tend to agree with you, spirituality is a state of being, but I think it is observable. Granted, spirituality doesn't jump out at you, like religion does, the criteria "perhaps" subjective, because individual spirituality differs, but it is my belief that you know spirituality when you see it. While I have not seen criteria for spirituality in print, I bet if I looked hard enough I might just find such a thing. You don't have to guess about someone's spirituality, if you take the time to listen and observe. It walks the walk even when religion sometimes doesn't. Just my humble opinion here.