emarine wrote:
Excellent reply buddy but I disagree with most of it... First off at the turn of the 19th century the indigenous people occupying what we call Palestine were 1/3 Jewish farmers & 2/3rds Arab farmers & nomadic headers... they all basically squatted on Ottoman empire land with a Jewish presence for well over 1000 years... seems to me at that point no one really cared... as the Zionist movement started to gain in the mid 20's the Egyptian's started shipping Arabs to Palestine as labor to Jewish settlements...The Jews would rather employ new Jews than the Arabs for typical human reasons which pissed off the Arabs returning to Egypt ... Then the Muslim Brotherhood was formed in Egypt inciting a religious hatred toward all Jews on what they claimed as Arab land... When Hitler stole the Jews wealth in Germany & started shipping Jew's to Palestine in 33 in large numbers the Arabs declared a holy war...Jihadi
Excellent reply buddy but I disagree with most of ... (
show quote)
Wait - I gotta stop here for a sec. So far in your rush history, you haven't mentioned anything about the displacement of the Palestinians. All of a sudden you're in 1933, like the displacement of Palestinians that started the moment Zionism started in the late 19th century is surgically removed from your narrative. I guess if it wasn't, you wouldn't be able to describe the demographics at the turn of the 19th century as being status quo over the previous thousand years. The truth is, Jews have already started mass migration from Eastern Europe and by the turn of the century it was becoming a new problem. A lot of these immigrants were not even Semitic people, they were Europeans, mostly Slavic, who had converted to Judaism and then, unfortunately to Zionism, which is a totally different thing.
Also, the Palestinians didn't spend 1000 years squatting on Ottoman land with a Jewish presence. The Jewish that were present WERE Palestinian. There were Palestinian Jews then just like there are Israeli Jews and American Jews today. And these Semitic people of Palestine, Arabs and Hebrews alike were not squatting anymore than the Greeks, Russians and Hungarians that were also ruled by the Turkish Empire.
unpause...
emarine wrote:
When Hitler stole the Jews wealth in Germany & started shipping Jew's to Palestine in 33 in large numbers the Arabs declared a holy war...Jihadi ...against all Jews as invaders of Arab lands...
It didn't all start with the Haavara Agreement bro... that was just another episode in an already long-running season. It *did* result in a spike in immigration but it was by no means the start. And yes, there were some extreme reactions from some of the Arabs, but it's not like we can pretend to be much better when we ourselves have such a strong Nativist culture... I mean, I hear American conservatives say some pretty hateful things about immigrants from Mexico. So you would think they would understand how the Palestinians felt, with all these European immigrants coming in and literally taking what they want.
emarine wrote:
when the Ottoman empire fell the British & French divided up all the lands from the Ottoman empire giving Palestine & Jorden to split between the Jews & Arabs... Balfour.. that didn't work because of the King of Jorden wouldn't accept the Arabs back which were mostly from Jorden to begin with
It's Jord
an... and no, the Arabs they were refusing were not from Jordan they're from Palestine. Two different provinces. The Balfour Agreement would have displaced a lot of Arabs from Palestine and Jordan didn't feel they should have to absorb the refugees just because the Jews wanted to kick them out of Palestine.
emarine wrote:
... as tensions grew the Arabs allied with the Nazis to exterminate the Jewish people in all of the ME... that plan failed as the Nazi's lost the 2nd war opening the door for the Zionist state that most of the free world accepted... the neo Nazi Muslim Brotherhood never ended their war with all the ME Jews not just the Zionists...
From what I can tell, the relationships between the Arab leaders and Nazi Germany were inconsistent and wrought with ulterior motives and corruption. Also, the Muslim Brotherhood has been banned in Egypt since 1958.
emarine wrote:
the entire anti Zionist movement started because the really religious Jews are still waiting for their God to lead the back to Israel & that hasn't happened yet... Extremist Islamic propaganda picked up on this anti Zionist BS and ran with it on public media seeking pity for the poor neo Nazi aggressors of never ending religious hatred & war...
The "really religious" Jews have apparently not forgotten that what makes a Jew, Jewish is his faith that God will lead them to Israel in Heaven. The Zionists are in the eyes of the true Rabbis, defiling God by leading people a material path to a material place they call Israel.
emarine wrote:
the people of Palestine are prisoners of neo Nazi terrorism ... there will never be any solution until the neo Nazis Arabs lose their hate BS like most humans with the ability to reason...
No, the people of Palestine are prisoners of Zionist terrorism. The will never be a solution as long as Zionists continue to push the Palestinian people out of existence.
emarine wrote:
by the way it was one of your post's that started me researching both sides of this issue several year's ago & 100's of hrs. of reading... thanks...
I'm glad I inspired you to research... just be careful - there's a lot of bullshit out there. ;)