Terbreugghen wrote:
I like your novel way of equating the two, but it seems a vast stretch.
Communists and libertarians hold a common position on the left for at least 5 separate issues:
Traditional social institutions: marriage, family, church etcetera
Libertarian: Absolutely no importance; must not exist because they serve to restrict the personal freedom of the individual by imposing societal norms on them.
Communism: Absolutely no importance; must not exist because they serve as tools of oppression.
Economic markets:
Libertarian: No regulation apart from market forces, i.e., supply and demand even though such markets may collapse since the profit motive in unregulated markets may lead to fraud and exploitation of labor, consumers and natural resources.
Communist: No regulation of any kind since markets do not exist
Economic planning:
Libertarian: Greatest possible centralization due to market forces to maximize profits.
Communist: Greatest possible centralization due to the efforts of the proletariat to maximize equality.
Human nature:
Libertarian: Least understanding of human nature; naïve ignorance of human nature in that libertarians believe humans will fairly complete with each other to maximize their individual self-interests.
Communist: Least understanding of human nature; naïve ignorance of human nature in that communists believe that humans will freely cooperate with each other in order to maximize their collective self-interests.
Nation state:
Libertarian: Unnecessary; does not exist in ideal libertarian society.
Communist: Unnecessary; does not exist in ideal communist society.
Libertarians and communists share a common position on the right for 1 issue:
Government:
Libertarian: Government is merely a source of oppression. Government officially does not exist in a libertarian setting, i.e., a state of nature, but it is actually embodied in the free market.
Communist: Government is merely a tool whereby the bourgeoisie oppresses the proletariat. Government officially does not exist in a communist setting, but it is actually embodied in the proletariat, i.e., mob rule.