This is a long read, 4 parts, but it worth wading through it. It gives an insight to various members of the supreme court. It exposes that the Supremes both left and right leaning base their decisions on their personal ideologies rather than the writings of the Constitution itself as they are supposed to do.
http://joemiller.us/2013/06/getting-it-wrong-about-getting-it-right/
Yankee Clipper wrote:
This is a long read, 4 parts, but it worth wading through it. It gives an insight to various members of the supreme court. It exposes that the Supremes both left and right leaning base their decisions on their personal ideologies rather than the writings of the Constitution itself as they are supposed to do.
http://joemiller.us/2013/06/getting-it-wrong-about-getting-it-right/That's where you're wrong, or at least that is where we will disagree. The Supreme Court Justice is there to "INTERPET" the Constitution.
Life experience will bring two people to two different interpretations.
You can say no that isn't correct, they are there to follow it, but like any writing, it will be read differently by two people, at two different times in history.
Why do you think there are contradictory rulings, over the century's? Interpretation!!
"Interpretation" says one thing to me: PARTISANSHIP. We're talking Justice here, people. Left is right and right is wrong.
AuntiE
Loc: 45th Least Free State
kevhurls wrote:
"Interpretation" says one thing to me: PARTISANSHIP. We're talking Justice here, people. Left is right and right is wrong.
An explanation of your last sentence, "Left is right and right is wrong." would be appreciated.
Yankee wrote:
Because some of the supreme justices thought they should rule by how they think a law should be interpreted, not how the Constitution itself addresses the issue. It's called legislating from the bench.
_____________________
I looked at your link, and it is just a lot of bible thumping clap trap.
your thought "how the Constitution itself addresses the issue."
That can only be an interpretation, two people will read a sentence differently.
Example:
I have heard Robert Frost's poem "Stopping by woods on a snowy evening" described as a deep study on life and death. I don't get that at all, I read it as a man stopping and enjoying "natures majesty"
Same words, different interpretations.
It is the same with a judge or justice, where you stand depends on where you sit.
AuntiE wrote:
An explanation of your last sentence, "Left is right and right is wrong." would be appreciated.
I see no need for an explanation, that line says all that needs to be said. That's why I didn't comment.
grazeem wrote:
Yankee wrote:
Because some of the supreme justices thought they should rule by how they think a law should be interpreted, not how the Constitution itself addresses the issue. It's called legislating from the bench.
_____________________
I looked at your link, and it is just a lot of bible thumping clap trap.
your thought "how the Constitution itself addresses the issue."
That can only be an interpretation, two people will read a sentence differently.
Example:
I have heard Robert Frost's poem "Stopping by woods on a snowy evening" described as a deep study on life and death. I don't get that at all, I read it as a man stopping and enjoying "natures majesty"
Same words, different interpretations.
It is the same with a judge or justice, where you stand depends on where you sit.
Yankee wrote: br br Because some of the supreme j... (
show quote)
Did you just make a degrading comment about the Bible? How very intolerant of you. You better be careful or you may find yourself in court for a hate crime.
If there is no interpretation, if things can only be read one way, as you say.
How come the Bible is read differently enough, for there to be, only God knows, different churches.
The Catholics have one Bible, and the Protestants another, but there are many different brands of church, using the King James Bible.
If there is only one way to read something, how can that be.
It can't.
Same with the Constitution
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.