One Political Plaza - Home of politics
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main
Finally Science and religion may be becoming friends.
Page <<first <prev 35 of 46 next> last>>
Jun 14, 2016 21:00:53   #
son of witless
 
nwtk2007 wrote:
Well, I hope you don't lump me into that category. I have found that the "Christian haters" are generally just not to fond of being told they are going to hell, or are going to face judgment or are being told that they lack that special connection to god to be able to understand the bible, etc, etc.

Many have also had bad experiences in their Christian backgrounds and have a chip on their shoulder about it also. They are actually believers who are turning away for the wrong reasons.

At any rate son of witless, I enjoy our exchanges.
Well, I hope you don't lump me into that category.... (show quote)


Let me tell you a little of my journey. I had a holy roller grandmother who bounced my mother off walls growing up. She used to watch me when I was little and I got a little of that. I had my period of anti religious rebellion. Later in life I came back to Christianity because I found not all Christians were my battle ax Grandma. I also found out about her suffering abuse, so the holy rolling was from something else.

As I came back to Christianity I found I had more in common with Christians and found I really could not stand most anti Christians.

Reply
Jun 14, 2016 22:40:57   #
nwtk2007 Loc: Texas
 
son of witless wrote:
Let me tell you a little of my journey. I had a holy roller grandmother who bounced my mother off walls growing up. She used to watch me when I was little and I got a little of that. I had my period of anti religious rebellion. Later in life I came back to Christianity because I found not all Christians were my battle ax Grandma. I also found out about her suffering abuse, so the holy rolling was from something else.

As I came back to Christianity I found I had more in common with Christians and found I really could not stand most anti Christians.
Let me tell you a little of my journey. I had a ho... (show quote)


Sounds pretty crazy. Amazing the abuse that goes on.

I too enjoy Christians. They are usually good people. If they'd not press the belief in the old stories or the miracle magic, I'd be fine. I go to a church with my lady friend. They are always welcoming, so I shouldn't criticize their beliefs. And they listen to my lack thereof. They worry about me and pray for me. But not obnoxiously.

They say I challenge their Bible knowledge so they always like to hear my take on things.

Works for me. I should probably do their yard or something.

Reply
Jun 14, 2016 22:42:21   #
Docadhoc Loc: Elsewhere
 
bdamage wrote:
It's "murder" Doc. "God and man and does not support" murder.

Luke 22:36

Then said he unto them, "But now, he that hath a purse, let him take it, and likewise his scrip: and he that hath no sword, let him sell his garment, and buy one."


And Christ gave them two swords.

And.one was used.to cut the ear off a servant of a high.priest. And Christ healed the servant.

No one was killed nor was killing intended.

Reply
 
 
Jun 15, 2016 01:33:57   #
Docadhoc Loc: Elsewhere
 
nwtk2007 wrote:
Sounds pretty crazy. Amazing the abuse that goes on.

I too enjoy Christians. They are usually good people. If they'd not press the belief in the old stories or the miracle magic, I'd be fine. I go to a church with my lady friend. They are always welcoming, so I shouldn't criticize their beliefs. And they listen to my lack thereof. They worry about me and pray for me. But not obnoxiously.

They say I challenge their Bible knowledge so they always like to hear my take on things.

Works for me. I should probably do their yard or something.
Sounds pretty crazy. Amazing the abuse that goes ... (show quote)


There are Christians who.push, but most Christians are good folks who don't push. I don't.push at all until I hear someone bad mouthing my faith. Then I speak.up. if these anti Christians could keep their opinion to themselves there would be no problem.

Reply
Jun 15, 2016 07:56:08   #
PeterS
 
Docadhoc wrote:
I skirt nothing. You limit God by trying to determine His actions.. He will do what He will do. He knows all the.permutations of His actions and inactions. So what? You seem to think because He knows in advance, that somehow it means He influences the outcomes. Free will can cause many potential outcomes. Again, so what? Knowing the outcome does not mean influencing that outcome.

By treating individuals as individuals, I don"t mean me. If I had meant that I would have said so. I mean don't blame Christianity for your shortcomings or the experiences you have had. Blame the particular individuals involved, not the religion.

You were taught by people trying to rationalize God. It doesn't work
Man's mind cannot fully conceive God's.

You were taught by people telling you their opinion. Nothing more.
I skirt nothing. You limit God by trying to deter... (show quote)


God exists in our imagination. Only the imagination limits god. And let me ask you--if your child was Adolph Hitler and before you even conceived him you know what and who he would become, are you telling me you aren't influencing the outcome! The god of our imagination is playing dice knowing the outcome of every roll he makes. Aside from playing a very boring game he is fully responsible for the game that is being played. You think you have free will? So what. It means nothing in a world where the outcome is known before the game is even played.

And you did hit one thing squarely on the head. God is irrational. Man is a creature of reason and no, the rational mind cannot understand the irrational mind of a god. And aside from the physical laws of nature Doc--everything is opinion. What it comes down to is whether your opinion is created through rationalism or irrationalism. One leads to a rational certainty and the other, by definition, is chaos...

Reply
Jun 15, 2016 08:02:39   #
lindajoy Loc: right here with you....
 
PeterS wrote:
God exists in our imagination. Only the imagination limits god. And let me ask you--if your child was Adolph Hitler and before you even conceived him you know what and who he would become, are you telling me you aren't influencing the outcome! The god of our imagination is playing dice knowing the outcome of every roll he makes. Aside from playing a very boring game he is fully responsible for the game that is being played. You think you have free will? So what. It means nothing in a world where the outcome is known before the game is even played.

And you did hit one thing squarely on the head. God is irrational. Man is a creature of reason and no, the rational mind cannot understand the irrational mind of a god. And aside from the physical laws of nature Doc--everything is opinion. What it comes down to is whether your opinion is created through rationalism or irrationalism. One leads to a rational certainty and the other, by definition, is chaos...
God exists in our imagination. Only the imaginatio... (show quote)


Your mind is your best friend or worst enemy~~I believe as I do and you believe as you do..I respect that, period..

Our choices for whatever reason are also just that..Some believe choosing to be good falls within their sense of balance as the person they are..Some believe we have a code or laws of the Bible that guide us..Both have the same end result, a choice between good and bad and the world smiles with you.........

Reply
Jun 15, 2016 08:31:53   #
PeterS
 
Docadhoc wrote:
That is exactly what I said.

When any group.of "religious"people kill, they are not following the edicts of their religion. The exception being Islam wherein the Quoran says kill the infidel.

No other religion supports murder that I know of, therefor when a group of "religious" people begin killing for any reason including for their religion, they are operating outside their religion's edicts. Therefore you do not vilify the religion. Vilify the people.

The New Testament is the new covenant between God and man and does not support killing. This is the law we live by today. Not the covenant of the Old Testament. The northetn Irish can claim what they wish but they are not doing what they do with God's approval.

Again, treat the sinner as an individual and do not blame the religion. Calling oneself a Christian does not mean the individual is living as a Christian.
That is exactly what I said. br br When any group... (show quote)


So are you saying those who follow the old testament are mistaken?

And I am finding this really curious. I stated earlier someone who had faith in god would need no gun as Christ was his protector. You are saying that Christ does not support killing. You said I was wrong but if Christ doesn't support killing how so?

Reply
 
 
Jun 15, 2016 08:33:39   #
lindajoy Loc: right here with you....
 
PeterS wrote:
So are you saying those who follow the old testament are mistaken?

And I am finding this really curious. I stated earlier someone who had faith in god would need no gun as Christ was his protector. You are saying that Christ does not support killing. You said I was wrong but if Christ doesn't support killing how so?


The Lord helps those whom help themself as well.....God didn't give us brains to be stupid..............

Reply
Jun 15, 2016 08:55:51   #
PeterS
 
lindajoy wrote:
Your mind is your best friend or worst enemy~~I believe as I do and you believe as you do..I respect that, period..

Our choices for whatever reason are also just that..Some believe choosing to be good falls within their sense of balance as the person they are..Some believe we have a code or laws of the Bible that guide us..Both have the same end result, a choice between good and bad and the world smiles with you.........
Your mind is your best friend or worst enemy~~I be... (show quote)


I am simply talking about what choice means when one creates an omnipotent god. Jefferson and his fellow deists believed that god was simply the power that created the universe and therefore, indirectly, the force that created us. They didn't believe that god interacted with man or was there to guide us down any particular path. That was up to man and why they created a government where man was free to worship god but gods influence stopped there. If god exists, that would be the type of god, as it is fully irrational to think any other way. Doc and his fellow CC's are at home in the world of irrationalism. I am not condemning them for that only saying that they would be better off to admit what, and how, they believe.

I started college at the University of Albuquerque, which had been called 'The University of St Joseph on the Rio Grande', and was a Catholic college that required 12 hours of theology to graduate. The first thing I was taught in Philosophy of Religion was the principles of Rationalism and Irrationalism and how one guides Man and how the other guides God and it's the conflicts between the rational and irrational where Man is tested.

Doc and others think I don't know what I'm talking about but I understand too well.

Believe as you like Linda--both theologically and politically--that will never change my opinion of you. And for everyone their minds are their best friends or worst enemies. I am comfortable with mine far more than when I trying to resolve the conflicts between reason and theology...

Reply
Jun 15, 2016 09:22:34   #
lindajoy Loc: right here with you....
 
PeterS wrote:
I am simply talking about what choice means when one creates an omnipotent god. Jefferson and his fellow deists believed that god was simply the power that created the universe and therefore, indirectly, the force that created us. They didn't believe that god interacted with man or was there to guide us down any particular path. That was up to man and why they created a government where man was free to worship god but gods influence stopped there. If god exists, that would be the type of god, as it is fully irrational to think any other way. Doc and his fellow CC's are at home in the world of irrationalism. I am not condemning them for that only saying that they would be better off to admit what, and how, they believe.

I started college at the University of Albuquerque, which had been called 'The University of St Joseph on the Rio Grande', and was a Catholic college that required 12 hours of theology to graduate. The first thing I was taught in Philosophy of Religion was the principles of Rationalism and Irrationalism and how one guides Man and how the other guides God and it's the conflicts between the rational and irrational where Man is tested.

Doc and others think I don't know what I'm talking about but I understand too well.

Believe as you like Linda--both theologically and politically--that will never change my opinion of you. And for everyone their minds are their best friends or worst enemies. I am comfortable with mine far more than when I trying to resolve the conflicts between reason and theology...
I am simply talking about what choice means when o... (show quote)


You have read the Federalist papers, as have I ..So much to learn in what our founding fathers were concerned with and their personal views of things...I agree with what you are saying as well to a degree..I am also saying we believe as we do regardless of what others want us to believe and the "learning process" of those topics enhance, good or bad...

Theologically or politically my opinion of you remains measured in the man I have come to know and am honored in your friendship, period..And the pictures are done...

Reply
Jun 15, 2016 11:49:31   #
Artemis
 
Docadhoc wrote:
There are Christians who.push, but most Christians are good folks who don't push. I don't.push at all until I hear someone bad mouthing my faith. Then I speak.up. if these anti Christians could keep their opinion to themselves there would be no problem.



Comes down to every man's truth is his own. It's not about accepting someone else's truth but accepting what they believe for themselves.

Reply
 
 
Jun 15, 2016 12:12:01   #
mwdegutis Loc: Illinois
 
Artemis wrote:
Comes down to every man's truth is his own. It's not about accepting someone else's truth but accepting what they believe for themselves.

So truth is relative and there's no such thing as absolute truth?

Reply
Jun 15, 2016 14:19:57   #
Artemis
 
mwdegutis wrote:
So truth is relative and there's no such thing as absolute truth?



Proven facts are truths, yet it's still relative, you can tell someone an undeniable truth yet they can simply choose not to believe it, in that sense it is relative. Take the discussion on global warming... a perfect example.

Reply
Jun 15, 2016 14:25:25   #
mwdegutis Loc: Illinois
 
Artemis wrote:
Proven facts are truths, yet it's still relative, you can tell someone an undeniable truth yet they can simply choose not to believe it, in that sense it is relative. tae the discussion on global warming for a perfect example.

You didn't answer my question...Is there no such thing as absolute truth because according to your logic murder is not wrong because someone chooses not to believe it is wrong.

Reply
Jun 15, 2016 15:33:45   #
Artemis
 
mwdegutis wrote:
You didn't answer my question...Is there no such thing as absolute truth because according to your logic murder is not wrong because someone chooses not to believe it is wrong.


I did answer you question, there is absolute fact for those that believe it to be absolute A man who commits murder is wrong in the eyes of all those who believe that to be true, but for example if a man kills someone under the pretense of a religious sacrificial gesture to their god, in the "eyes of his congregation" is it murder? Under his culture the answer would be no. He had done no wrong.

Does a soldier commit murder when fighting? The human mind can rationalize anything. We have laws we abide by, we do that in agreement to what we feel to be true to ourselves, by what we are taught and than follow...or not, as we do have free choice even if it leads to our own demise.

Reply
Page <<first <prev 35 of 46 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main
OnePoliticalPlaza.com - Forum
Copyright 2012-2024 IDF International Technologies, Inc.