Facebook Twitter RSS
USAPP
Go to...
A tale of two cities: How San Francisco surged forward while LA fell behind
Share this:
LASF authorsFor most of the twentieth century, the Los Angeles region had one of the countys best performing economies. But now, incomes of those in the San Francisco Bay area outpace those in LA by a third. In their new book, Michael Storper, Thomas Kemeny, Naji Makarem, & Taner Osman take a close look at how San Francisco has thrived while Los Angeles stagnated. They argue that the Bay Area created an ecosystem of invention and innovation that allowed Silicon Valley to arise and thrive, even as LAs industries remained largely siloed.
Cities and regions have very different fortunes over time, and it is hard to predict them. The ups and downs of big metropolitan areas make a huge difference to the people who live in them, creating and destroying opportunity. They drive people in and drive people away. The ups lead to flourishing public facilities, while the downs lead to deterioration of the urban environment.
It is one thing to observe the conditions that, on average, separate successful or rising regions from less successful ones. But the averages only get us so far. Underneath them are chains of events; pathways that are defined and can become self-reinforcing. Consider Greater Los Angeles and the San Francisco Bay Area, two urban centers that have diverged sharply in recent decades. In 1970 they had about equal per capita incomes, but, as Figure 1 show, today incomes of people in the Bay Area are one-third higher than in Southern California. The Bay Area is in a group of metropolitan areas that took the high road in terms of incomes, including New York, Chicago, Boston Washington DC and Philadelphia. Greater Los Angeless income growth is more like that of Detroit.
Figure 1 Evolution of per capita personal income, 1970-2012
Storper Fig 1
The evolution of per capita personal incomes in large metropolitan areas, 1970-2012. Source: Authors calculations using Bureau of Economic Affairs Regional Economic Accounts data.
All in all, the Bay Area is an example of how a region successfully enters the New Economy, while LAthe star economy among US regions for nearly 70 years in the twentieth centurydid much worse than its northern neighbor. How did this happen and what are the lessons we can learn from it?
At the outset, both cities could boast the initial building blocks that would, in the Bay Area, eventually flower into a booming tech industryin fact, in some ways these initial factors, such as the presence of world-class technology companies and the pool of highly-skilled engineers and technologists, looked more promising in LA than in San Francisco. LA made more semiconductors than the Bay Area in 1970. The first Internet message was sent from University of California, Los Angeles. LA was home base for mythical entrepreneurs for much of the twentieth century, from movies to aerospace. But once the age of IT arrived, all the Steve Jobs, Bill Hewletts and William Shockleysthe key entrepreneurs of the New Economy, were in the north, not the south.
Part of it might be luck. But, as the saying goes, fortune favors the prepared. And this is the real key to why San Francisco became the center of the world IT industry and LA did not.
Southern Californias firms, industries, and political leaders were conservative in facing this new world. LAs industries were largely siloed, with the worlds of Hollywood, aerospace, the creative industries, and academia separated from one another and no leadership groups to bring them together to mobilize for the New Economy. In contrast, the Bay Area had cross-fertilization mechanisms that allowed new skills and practices to emerge rapidly. The IT world blended older engineering communities with young hippie technologists and appropriate technology environmentalists, and both were mixed in with academic researchers. This created the unique user-friendly approach to new technologies that the Bay Area captured, while LAs tech firms remained oriented to their traditional clients in mass production and the military.
Economics and society interact. They come together in these organizational or relational structuresin firms, leadership groups, and attitudes or simply a sense of possibility. Regional business leadership in the Bay Area grasped the existence of the New Economy early on. In LA, leaders pushed policies for old economy revival, which reinforced the growing low-wage employment in that region. And the New Economy industries that arose in Orange County were big, but were second-stringers, applying traditional corporate models to new technologies, but not inventing them from the bottom up. LA never got the ecosystem of innovation and invention that the Bay Area created, even though LA had had the greatest innovation ecosystem of the first part of the twentieth century.
The story repeated itself with biotechnology. The early invention of gene splicing occurred almost simultaneously at the University of California San Francisco and City of Hope hospital in Hollywood. The early scientist-entrepreneurs were in both regions. The first big biotech firm, Amgen, established itself in LA. But Amgen quickly turned into a traditional companybig, go-it-alone, managed by MBAs, not scientists. Genentech went the other direction, following the Bay Area New Economy approach: small, nimble, with many spinoffs, managed by scientists, with a revolving door to an expanding community of spin-offs and networks of people with new ideas. Biotech became a big cluster in the Bay Area, a big company in LAbut the Bay Area won out, generating many more jobs than LA.
Hollywood was, and continues to be, LAs success story, the undisputed world capital of entertainment. Hollywood became a New Economy industry even before IT, by reshaping itself in the 1970s. But Hollywood is too small to carry the whole Southern California economy on its shoulders, and it is too isolated from the rest of the regions activities. The boards of directors of Hollywood firms do not contain people from tech and vice-versa. By contrast, both within the tech world and between tech and the rest of the Bay Area economy, boards of directors are networked: they talk across boundaries.
Both regions followed essentially the same economic policies, rather traditional in nature: mega-projects, tax incentives, and even job training, but these had little impact on the divergence in economic development between the two metro areas. Thats because such policies do not address the real issue: the capacity of regions to allow their labor, capital, and talent to combine and recombine in ways that follow the evolution of opportunities in the wider economic environment. The networks of groups and leaders in Los Angeles had few conversations about this (they were overly confident) and the conversations they had were backward looking. By contrast, the Bay Area strengthened its networksespecially through the Bay Area Councilfor such conversations to take place, and people there quickly understood that the old economy was old, and a new economy was there, from which they could innovate and prosper. LA had no equivalent of the Bay Area Council, but instead a fragmented world of different groups who were mostly backward-looking.
Greater LA is still a relatively wealthy region, full of creativity, cultural power, good academic institutions, and a talent base from around the world. What it lacks is a way of pulling all this together.
The Bay Area is perhaps the worlds leading tech economy, wealthy and beautiful. But the Bay Area should not rest on its laurels. In 1960, Detroit was an undisputed capital of American industrial might. Nothing lasts forever.
rise and fall bookThis article first appeared at the Stanford University Press blog, and is based on the new book,The Rise and Fall of Urban Economies, which draws on economics, sociology, political science, and geography to shed light on the economic development of metropolitan regions.
Featured image credits: Daniel Ronan (Flickr, CC-BY-2.0); Dave Reichert (Flickr, CC-BY-NC-2.0)
Please read our comments policy before commenting.
Note: This article gives the views of the author, and not the position of USAPP American Politics and Policy, nor the London School of Economics.
Shortened URL for this post:
http://bit.ly/1kmifhl _________________________________
About the authors
Michael Storper 80x108Michael Storper University of California, Los Angeles
Michael Storper is Professor of Urban Planning at the University of California, Los Angeles. He is co-author of The Rise and Fall of Urban Economies: Lessons from San Francisco and Los Angeles.
Thomas Kemeny 80x108Thomas Kemeny University of Southampton
Thomas Kemeny is Lecturer in Human Geography at the University of Southampton and co-author ofThe Rise and Fall of Urban Economies: Lessons from San Francisco and Los Angeles.
Naji Makarem 80x108Naji Makarem University College London
Naji Makarem is Lecturer in the Bartlett Development Planning Unit at University College London and co-author of The Rise and Fall of Urban Economies: Lessons from San Francisco and Los Angeles.
Taner Osman 80x108Taner Osman University of California, Los Angeles
Taner Osman is an instructor in the Department of Urban Planning at the University of California, Los Angeles and co-author of The Rise and Fall of Urban Economies: Lessons from San Francisco and Los Angeles.
Print Friendly
Related
Regulatory constraints on supply are a key factor in San Franciscos affordable housing crisis.
Regulatory constraints on supply are a key factor in San Franciscos affordable housing crisis.
In "Nils Kok"
Presidential candidates in 2016 should not underestimate the power of urban identityit allowed Obama to halve Bushs urban victories
Presidential candidates in 2016 should not underestimate the power of urban identityit allowed Obama to halve Bushs urban victories
In "Elections and party politics across the US"
Book Review: Street Level: Los Angeles in the Twenty-First Century by Rob Sullivan
Book Review: Street Level: Los Angeles in the Twenty-First Century by Rob Sullivan
In "Ben Mueller"
November 2nd, 2015|Featured, LSE Comment, Michael Storper, Naji Makarem, Taner Osman, Thomas Kemeny, Urban and regional policies|0 Comments
Previous post
Leave A Comment
Name (required)
Email (required)
Website
Comment...
POST COMMENT
Notify me of follow-up comments by email.
Notify me of new posts by email.
More like this
Neighborhood diversity plays a limited role in the residential preferences of creative class workers in Chicago
Neighborhood diversity plays a limited role in the residential preferences of creative class workers in Chicago
States with more generous welfare policies are more likely to protect vulnerable African-American communities from environmental risks.
States with more generous welfare policies are more likely to protect vulnerable African-American communities from environmental risks.
Immigration is an important dimension in how we understand gentrification across US cities.
Immigration is an important dimension in how we understand gentrification across US cities.
In Los Angeles, increasing neighborhood diversity means that segregation is on the decline.
In Los Angeles, increasing neighborhood diversity means that segregation is on the decline.
Recent posts
Book Review: The Courage to Act: A Memoir of a Crisis and its Aftermath by Ben S. Bernanke
Book Review: The Courage to Act: A Memoir of a Crisis and its Aftermath by Ben S. Bernanke
Little interest in New Jerseys elections, Texas abysmal vaccination rate, and Illinois Rauner doubles down on anti-union policies: US state blog round up for 24 30 October
Little interest in New Jerseys elections, Texas abysmal vaccination rate, and Illinois Rauner doubles down on anti-union policies: US state blog round up for 24 30 October
The promise to change the Canadian electoral system is a bold commitment, and one that will be tough to meet
The promise to change the Canadian electoral system is a bold commitment, and one that will be tough to meet
Rubio tops GOP debate at Jebs expense, Ryan becomes Speaker, and Congresss bipartisan budget deal: US national blog round up for 24 30 October
Rubio tops GOP debate at Jebs expense, Ryan becomes Speaker, and Congresss bipartisan budget deal: US national blog round up for 24 30 October
Follow USAPP on Twitter
Follow USAPP on Facebook
LSE Review of Books Visit our sister blog: British Politics and Policy at LSE
RSS LATEST LSE EVENTS PODCASTS
Shaken but not Stirred? The Banking System Seven Years after the Crisis [Audio]
October 29, 2015
Towards the Flame: empire, war and the end of Tsarist Russia [Audio]
October 29, 2015
Anthropology and Development: challenges for the 21st century [Audio]
October 28, 2015
A Theory of Everything: evolution, history and the shape of things to come [Audio]
October 27, 2015
Delivering the Sustainable Development Goals: a new partnership between state and private sector [Audio]
October 27, 2015
Europe 2.0: The new challenges of the European Union [Audio]
October 27, 2015
Jobs only for the most skilled at the right age? [Audio]
October 26, 2015
Paris and Beyond: how will we gain traction and build momentum for the orderly transition to a zero carbon and resilient economy? [Audio]
October 22, 2015
Too Many Children Left Behind: the US achievement gap in comparative perspective [Audio]
October 21, 2015
Justice, Accountability and Human Rights in India [Audio]
October 21, 2015
LSE Business Review Visit our sister blog: LSE Business Review blog
RSS LATEST FROM LSE BUSINESS REVIEW
Zero growth wouldnt bring the world anywhere near the necessary reduction in CO2 emissions
November 2, 2015
The Courage To Act: A Memoir of a Crisis and its Aftermath Book Review
November 1, 2015
Independent central banks are here to control inflation, but they help maintain fiscal discipline too
October 31, 2015
As sovereign wealth funds come of age, they grow rapidly but face a number of challenges
October 30, 2015
Culturally diverse teams may require more central coordination than others
October 29, 2015
Learn fast, design and never assume youre right: the three principles of fast-growth companies
October 28, 2015
When even central banks use Twitter to communicate, the markets turn to social media
October 27, 2015
Growth of emerging markets, new technologies and urbanisation are historic world shifts
October 26, 2015
Chinas Challenges Book Review
October 25, 2015
Tata shows that private governance of adapting for climate change can work with clearer incentives
October 24, 2015
LSE Review of Books Visit our sister blog: LSE Review of Books
RSS LSE PODCASTS
Shaken but not Stirred? The Banking System Seven Years after the Crisis [Audio]
October 29, 2015
Towards the Flame: empire, war and the end of Tsarist Russia [Audio]
October 29, 2015
Anthropology and Development: challenges for the 21st century [Audio]
October 28, 2015
A Theory of Everything: evolution, history and the shape of things to come [Audio]
October 27, 2015
Delivering the Sustainable Development Goals: a new partnership between state and private sector [Audio]
October 27, 2015
Europe 2.0: The new challenges of the European Union [Audio]
October 27, 2015
Jobs only for the most skilled at the right age? [Audio]
October 26, 2015
Paris and Beyond: how will we gain traction and build momentum for the orderly transition to a zero carbon and resilient economy? [Audio]
October 22, 2015
Paris and Beyond: how will we gain traction and build momentum for the orderly transition to a zero carbon and resilient economy? [Video]
October 22, 2015
Too Many Children Left Behind: the US achievement gap in comparative perspective [Audio]
October 21, 2015
Impact of Social Sciences blog Visit our sister blog: LSE Impact of Social Sciences Blog
RSS LATEST FROM LSE RESEARCH ONLINE
Personal sovereignty and our moral rights to non-interference
November 2, 2015
Towards a radical re-appropriation: gender, development and neoliberal feminism
November 2, 2015
The conditionality of the trade-off between government responsiveness and effectiveness: the impact of minority status and polls in the Canadian House of Commons
November 2, 2015
Assisted conception and surrogacy in the United Kingdom
October 30, 2015
The relationship between medical law and good medical ethics
October 30, 2015
A response to saviour siblings: a relational approach to the welfare of the child in selective reproduction
October 30, 2015
DIY abortion and harm reduction
October 30, 2015
The law and DIY assisted conception
October 30, 2015
Widening access : improving police relations with hard to reach groups
October 30, 2015
Risks and responses: drug prevention and youth justice
October 30, 2015
Facebook Twitter RSS
CC BY-NC 3.0 2015 LSE USAPP
This work by LSE USApp blog is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported.