JFlorio wrote:
It can be done. Just not called carpet bombing. All semantics. I could care less if we carpet-bombed the Taliban.
It may not be that great of a strategy, 1. it is not legal 2. it is difficult to carpet bomb and only destroy the Taliban, most likely kill civilian women and children.
The preferred legal precision bombing
Precision bombing refers to the attempted aerial bombing of a target with some degree of accuracy, with the aim of limiting collateral damage. An example would be destroying a single building in a built-up area causing minimal damage to the surroundings. Precision bombing was initially tried by both the Allied and Central Powers during World War I, however, it was found to be ineffective because the technology did not allow for sufficient accuracy. Therefore, the air forces turned to area bombardment, which inevitably brought about civilian casualties.[1] "Precision bombing" was notably attempted by the United States Army Air Forces over Europe during World War II, as it was believed that heavy bombers could accurately bomb targets from high altitude using the Norden bombsight. Since then, the development and adoption of guided munitions have greatly increased the accuracy of aerial bombing. Because the accuracy achieved in the bombing is dependent on the available technology, the "precision" of precision bombing is relative to the time period.
Precision has always been recognized as an important attribute of weapon development. The noted military theorist, strategist, and historian Major-General J. F. C. Fuller considered "accuracy of aim" one of the five recognizable attributes of weaponry, together with a range of action, striking power, the volume of fire, and portability.
Increasingly, U.S. forces have used bombs with highly precise laser-guidance systems and those that rely on satellite guidance gear. Satellite-guided bombs can be used more effectively than others in bad weather.
One new weapon, the Joint Direct Attack Munition, or JDAM, is a free-falling bomb that has been fitted with a satellite-guidance "kit" and a special tail section that allows it to correct itself and maneuver -- albeit for relatively short distances -- to its target. It still needs to be dropped by an aircraft into a small target area, called a "basket," in much the same way that old-fashioned gravity bombs are deployed.
A JDAM can correct for sudden wind in midflight, but it can be thrown off if hit by heavy crosswinds near the ground. And the electronic signals used by the satellite guidance system can be interrupted by jamming by a sophisticated enemy or inadvertently by other transmitters used by U.S. forces.
Laser-guided bombs are the most precise of all because they follow a thin beam to a precise point on the ground.
"In the real world, this stuff works fairly well most of the time, but not perfectly well all of the time," said John Pike, a defense analyst with GlobalSecurity.org, a research organization in Virginia.