LA County Proposes $1,000 Monthly Guaranteed Income
May 17, 2021 14:34:17 #
LA County Proposes $1,000 Monthly Guaranteed Income
Los Angeles County’s supervision board will v**e on a proposal which will establish a “poverty alleviation policy agenda” and seeks to give direct payments to some residents living at or below the poverty line.
The proposal will “explore guaranteed income and other measures of poverty alleviation as permanent County policy, not just as an emergency measure to help with this crisis.”
“For the past five decades, the Black unemployment rate has remained close to double the white unemployment rate, even in labor markets where overall unemployment rates were in the very low single digits.1 Racial discrimination by employers continues to be a significant factor. Housing discrimination and exclusionary zoning have kept Black families and other families of color locked out of neighborhoods from which good jobs, good schools, parks, and community amenities are easily accessible. We must fundamentally shift the idea that people who face financial insecurity have somehow failed, and instead recognize that it is the inequity and lack of access built into our economy and government assistance programs that have failed us.”
County Supervisors Holly Mitchell and Sheila Kuehl emphasized in their proposal that “economic inequity exacerbated by the C****-** p******c is affecting our County’s public health, resulting in large disparities in family stability, economic stability, health and mental wellness, education, employment, public safety, criminal justice and housing.”
If approved, the plan would cost $36 Million dollars and provide basic income to about 1000 residents. The county would need to raise the amount needed.
***************************************************************************************
MOTION BY SUPERVISORS HOLLY J. MITCHELL AND May 18, 2021
SHEILA KUEHL
ESTABLISHING A LOS ANGELES COUNTY POVERTY ALLEVIATION POLICY AGENDA
AND CREATING A COUNTYWIDE GUARANTEED INCOME PROGRAM
Long before the dual p******c - both public health and economic – caused by C****-**,
the United States’ (U.S.) and Los Angeles’ economies have been plagued by instability, much of
it caused by staggering levels of ine******y. As we endeavor to create a more resilient economy
and Los Angeles County (County), we must explore guaranteed income and other measures of
poverty alleviation as permanent County policy, not just as an emergency measure to help with
this crisis. The c****av***s crisis has heightened and made more vivid what was already clear to
many: the inequities in our economy have been a matter of life and death for many of our most
vulnerable County residents. Prior to the C****-** epidemic, the safety net failed to address the
structural issues that have been keeping many children and their families trapped in poverty.
For the past five decades, the Black unemployment rate has remained close to double the
white unemployment rate, even in labor markets where overall unemployment rates were in the
very low single digits.1 Racial discrimination by employers continues to be a significant factor.
Housing discrimination and exclusionary zoning have kept Black families and other families of
color locked out of neighborhoods from which good jobs, good schools, parks, and community
amenities are easily accessible. We must fundamentally shift the idea that people who face
financial insecurity have somehow failed, and instead recognize that it is the inequity and lack of
access built into our economy and government assistance programs that have failed us.
Additionally, we know that occupational segregation by race and g****r is a factor, and that
1 On the Persistence of the Black-White Unemployment Gap. Center for American Progress. Olugbenga Ajilore,
February 24, 2020. MOTION BY SUPERVISORS HOLLY J. MITCHELL AND SHEILA KUEHL
MAY 18, 2021
PAGE 2
female-dominated industries have lost the most jobs since the onset of the p******c. For example,
in December 2020, the U.S. economy lost 140,000 net jobs, and all the jobs lost were held by
women, with women losing 156,000 jobs and men gaining 16,000. Moreover, even before the
p******c, women and people of color tended to be working in lower-paying jobs than their
counterparts, and these disparities are amplified at the intersection of race and g****r.
To combat poverty and the inequitable distribution of wealth, there is growing community of
practice supporting guaranteed income programs in cities and counties across the nation. The
concept of guaranteed income (sometimes referred to as universal basic income) dates back
centuries when philosopher Thomas Paine called for a basic income in the U.S. in the late 1770s.
Martin Luther King, Jr. supported the concept to alleviate poverty in the 1960s. Negative income
tax trials were conducted in Seattle and New Jersey starting in the 1960s. In recent years,
countries such as Finland have successfully implemented basic income programs.
Lead by former Stockton mayor Michael Tubbs, Mayors for a Guaranteed Income was
launched to help incubate these programs, giving groups of mostly lower-income residents a few
hundred dollars to $1,000 monthly with no restrictions on allowable spending for a year or more.
It is also taking shape in the U.S. Congress through a variety of proposed tax credits or allowances.
The movement for guaranteed income, started by Stockton, has gained currency amid the
economic carnage wrought by the C****-** p******c, which has left 10 million Americans
unemployed, and heightened awareness of racial inequities after the death of G****e F***d while
in police custody. A Guaranteed Income program provides households with financial stability
during sharp economic swings, alleviates stress and broadens recipients’ horizons, allowing them
the time to complete deferred schooling and plans to fully participate in their communities.
Importantly, these programs come without the scrutiny and work requirements of programs such
as welfare and food stamps.
With a once-in-a-generation opportunity to rebuild our economy and leverage potential
Federal stimulus dollars, the Board of Supervisors (Board) seeks to declare equitable economic
recovery, with the implementation of a guaranteed income program at its foundation, as a Board
Directed Priority. MOTION BY SUPERVISORS HOLLY J. MITCHELL AND SHEILA KUEHL
MAY 18, 2021
PAGE 3
In 2015, the Board established four Board Priorities, now referred to as Board Directed
Priorities (Priorities): The Sheriff's Department/Justice Reform; Child Protection; Health
Integration; and the Homeless Initiative. Since then, the Board has added four additional priorities:
Environmental Oversight and Monitoring, Immigration, and adopting an Antir****m Diversity and
Inclusion Policy Agenda. A Board Directed Priority is the Board's collective response to complex
challenges that have adverse impacts on the health, safety, and well-being of County residents
and/or its institutions. Given the gravity of the economic recovery ahead and the opportunity to reimagine economic opportunity and create wealth building opportunities, the County must address
poverty alleviation at a regional level, with a sustained focus, and include partnerships with
philanthropy and the private sector.
WE THEREFORE MOVE THAT THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS:
1) Recognize, affirm, and declare that poverty and economic opportunity is a matter of public
health in Los Angeles County (County) and that economic inequity exacerbated by the
C****-** p******c is affecting our County’s public health, resulting in large disparities in
family stability, economic stability, health and mental wellness, education, employment,
public safety, criminal justice and housing.
2) Direct the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) to establish a ninth Board Directed Priority to
establish a Countywide Poverty Alleviation Initiative (Initiative) that builds on the work of
multiple County departments and serves as a regional leader to address the growing wealth
gap across multiple cross-sections of the County population and report back to the Board
in writing in 90 days with:
a. a strategic plan (Plan) and policy platform articulating the mission, vision, values and
timeline with deliverables of the Initiative;
b. establishment of a Countywide oversight mechanism and incubation of the Initiative
that includes collaboration with other initiatives and programs currently housed in the
CEO’s office including the Anti-r****m, Diversity and Inclusion Initiative, the
Homeless Initiative, and the Economic Development Unit, and that is dedicated to
working with the Board to implement the Plan and priority programs of Initiative;MOTION BY SUPERVISORS HOLLY J. MITCHELL AND SHEILA KUEHL
MAY 18, 2021
PAGE 4
c. a comprehensive set of policy recommendations for Board consideration that could
be enacted to close the racial and g****r wealth gap and provide opportunities for
economic opportunity and self-sufficiency; and.
d. plans to coordinate with the City of Los Angeles and any other jurisdictions
throughout the County who endeavor to undertake similar poverty alleviation
measures.
3) Direct the CEO to, within 60 days, establish a Guaranteed Income Pilot Program (Pilot)
Implementation Plan within the Initiative. The Pilot shall include:
a. Within 30 days, identify appropriative funding and administrative support for a Pilot
to serve no fewer than 1000 County residents for three years;
b. Working with the Board, within 30 days engage a consultant or consultants to design
the Pilot based on best practices from other jurisdictions including: identification of
target population, method to choose participants, engaging community
organizations, advocates and service providers, and mechanism for disbursing
funding;
c. Engage a consultant or consultants to conduct research throughout the duration and
beyond the length of the Pilot and determine appropriate impact metrics to
demonstrate the efficacy of such a Pilot for the target population;
d. Establish a target population that will receive, at a minimum, a monthly income
support of $1,000 and consider as part of the Pilot’s target population the inclusion
of women living at or below poverty level who were released from incarceration in
the last seven years, T***sition Age Youth (TAY) head of households, and/or
Domestic Violence Survivors head of households; and
e. Within 180 days, return with a recommendation for long-term Countywide
administration of such an Initiative.MOTION BY SUPERVISORS HOLLY J. MITCHELL AND SHEILA KUEHL
MAY 18, 2021
PAGE 5
4) Direct the CEO to recommend and advocate for relevant legislative policies that improve
outcomes and reduce racial disparities and support local, regional, state, and federal
initiatives that support Guaranteed Income as a poverty alleviation policy and that facilitate
full receipt of all state and Federal benefits regardless of participation in a Guaranteed
Income program.
https://trishintel.com/la-county-proposes-1000-monthly-guaranteed-income/
Los Angeles County’s supervision board will v**e on a proposal which will establish a “poverty alleviation policy agenda” and seeks to give direct payments to some residents living at or below the poverty line.
The proposal will “explore guaranteed income and other measures of poverty alleviation as permanent County policy, not just as an emergency measure to help with this crisis.”
“For the past five decades, the Black unemployment rate has remained close to double the white unemployment rate, even in labor markets where overall unemployment rates were in the very low single digits.1 Racial discrimination by employers continues to be a significant factor. Housing discrimination and exclusionary zoning have kept Black families and other families of color locked out of neighborhoods from which good jobs, good schools, parks, and community amenities are easily accessible. We must fundamentally shift the idea that people who face financial insecurity have somehow failed, and instead recognize that it is the inequity and lack of access built into our economy and government assistance programs that have failed us.”
County Supervisors Holly Mitchell and Sheila Kuehl emphasized in their proposal that “economic inequity exacerbated by the C****-** p******c is affecting our County’s public health, resulting in large disparities in family stability, economic stability, health and mental wellness, education, employment, public safety, criminal justice and housing.”
If approved, the plan would cost $36 Million dollars and provide basic income to about 1000 residents. The county would need to raise the amount needed.
***************************************************************************************
MOTION BY SUPERVISORS HOLLY J. MITCHELL AND May 18, 2021
SHEILA KUEHL
ESTABLISHING A LOS ANGELES COUNTY POVERTY ALLEVIATION POLICY AGENDA
AND CREATING A COUNTYWIDE GUARANTEED INCOME PROGRAM
Long before the dual p******c - both public health and economic – caused by C****-**,
the United States’ (U.S.) and Los Angeles’ economies have been plagued by instability, much of
it caused by staggering levels of ine******y. As we endeavor to create a more resilient economy
and Los Angeles County (County), we must explore guaranteed income and other measures of
poverty alleviation as permanent County policy, not just as an emergency measure to help with
this crisis. The c****av***s crisis has heightened and made more vivid what was already clear to
many: the inequities in our economy have been a matter of life and death for many of our most
vulnerable County residents. Prior to the C****-** epidemic, the safety net failed to address the
structural issues that have been keeping many children and their families trapped in poverty.
For the past five decades, the Black unemployment rate has remained close to double the
white unemployment rate, even in labor markets where overall unemployment rates were in the
very low single digits.1 Racial discrimination by employers continues to be a significant factor.
Housing discrimination and exclusionary zoning have kept Black families and other families of
color locked out of neighborhoods from which good jobs, good schools, parks, and community
amenities are easily accessible. We must fundamentally shift the idea that people who face
financial insecurity have somehow failed, and instead recognize that it is the inequity and lack of
access built into our economy and government assistance programs that have failed us.
Additionally, we know that occupational segregation by race and g****r is a factor, and that
1 On the Persistence of the Black-White Unemployment Gap. Center for American Progress. Olugbenga Ajilore,
February 24, 2020. MOTION BY SUPERVISORS HOLLY J. MITCHELL AND SHEILA KUEHL
MAY 18, 2021
PAGE 2
female-dominated industries have lost the most jobs since the onset of the p******c. For example,
in December 2020, the U.S. economy lost 140,000 net jobs, and all the jobs lost were held by
women, with women losing 156,000 jobs and men gaining 16,000. Moreover, even before the
p******c, women and people of color tended to be working in lower-paying jobs than their
counterparts, and these disparities are amplified at the intersection of race and g****r.
To combat poverty and the inequitable distribution of wealth, there is growing community of
practice supporting guaranteed income programs in cities and counties across the nation. The
concept of guaranteed income (sometimes referred to as universal basic income) dates back
centuries when philosopher Thomas Paine called for a basic income in the U.S. in the late 1770s.
Martin Luther King, Jr. supported the concept to alleviate poverty in the 1960s. Negative income
tax trials were conducted in Seattle and New Jersey starting in the 1960s. In recent years,
countries such as Finland have successfully implemented basic income programs.
Lead by former Stockton mayor Michael Tubbs, Mayors for a Guaranteed Income was
launched to help incubate these programs, giving groups of mostly lower-income residents a few
hundred dollars to $1,000 monthly with no restrictions on allowable spending for a year or more.
It is also taking shape in the U.S. Congress through a variety of proposed tax credits or allowances.
The movement for guaranteed income, started by Stockton, has gained currency amid the
economic carnage wrought by the C****-** p******c, which has left 10 million Americans
unemployed, and heightened awareness of racial inequities after the death of G****e F***d while
in police custody. A Guaranteed Income program provides households with financial stability
during sharp economic swings, alleviates stress and broadens recipients’ horizons, allowing them
the time to complete deferred schooling and plans to fully participate in their communities.
Importantly, these programs come without the scrutiny and work requirements of programs such
as welfare and food stamps.
With a once-in-a-generation opportunity to rebuild our economy and leverage potential
Federal stimulus dollars, the Board of Supervisors (Board) seeks to declare equitable economic
recovery, with the implementation of a guaranteed income program at its foundation, as a Board
Directed Priority. MOTION BY SUPERVISORS HOLLY J. MITCHELL AND SHEILA KUEHL
MAY 18, 2021
PAGE 3
In 2015, the Board established four Board Priorities, now referred to as Board Directed
Priorities (Priorities): The Sheriff's Department/Justice Reform; Child Protection; Health
Integration; and the Homeless Initiative. Since then, the Board has added four additional priorities:
Environmental Oversight and Monitoring, Immigration, and adopting an Antir****m Diversity and
Inclusion Policy Agenda. A Board Directed Priority is the Board's collective response to complex
challenges that have adverse impacts on the health, safety, and well-being of County residents
and/or its institutions. Given the gravity of the economic recovery ahead and the opportunity to reimagine economic opportunity and create wealth building opportunities, the County must address
poverty alleviation at a regional level, with a sustained focus, and include partnerships with
philanthropy and the private sector.
WE THEREFORE MOVE THAT THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS:
1) Recognize, affirm, and declare that poverty and economic opportunity is a matter of public
health in Los Angeles County (County) and that economic inequity exacerbated by the
C****-** p******c is affecting our County’s public health, resulting in large disparities in
family stability, economic stability, health and mental wellness, education, employment,
public safety, criminal justice and housing.
2) Direct the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) to establish a ninth Board Directed Priority to
establish a Countywide Poverty Alleviation Initiative (Initiative) that builds on the work of
multiple County departments and serves as a regional leader to address the growing wealth
gap across multiple cross-sections of the County population and report back to the Board
in writing in 90 days with:
a. a strategic plan (Plan) and policy platform articulating the mission, vision, values and
timeline with deliverables of the Initiative;
b. establishment of a Countywide oversight mechanism and incubation of the Initiative
that includes collaboration with other initiatives and programs currently housed in the
CEO’s office including the Anti-r****m, Diversity and Inclusion Initiative, the
Homeless Initiative, and the Economic Development Unit, and that is dedicated to
working with the Board to implement the Plan and priority programs of Initiative;MOTION BY SUPERVISORS HOLLY J. MITCHELL AND SHEILA KUEHL
MAY 18, 2021
PAGE 4
c. a comprehensive set of policy recommendations for Board consideration that could
be enacted to close the racial and g****r wealth gap and provide opportunities for
economic opportunity and self-sufficiency; and.
d. plans to coordinate with the City of Los Angeles and any other jurisdictions
throughout the County who endeavor to undertake similar poverty alleviation
measures.
3) Direct the CEO to, within 60 days, establish a Guaranteed Income Pilot Program (Pilot)
Implementation Plan within the Initiative. The Pilot shall include:
a. Within 30 days, identify appropriative funding and administrative support for a Pilot
to serve no fewer than 1000 County residents for three years;
b. Working with the Board, within 30 days engage a consultant or consultants to design
the Pilot based on best practices from other jurisdictions including: identification of
target population, method to choose participants, engaging community
organizations, advocates and service providers, and mechanism for disbursing
funding;
c. Engage a consultant or consultants to conduct research throughout the duration and
beyond the length of the Pilot and determine appropriate impact metrics to
demonstrate the efficacy of such a Pilot for the target population;
d. Establish a target population that will receive, at a minimum, a monthly income
support of $1,000 and consider as part of the Pilot’s target population the inclusion
of women living at or below poverty level who were released from incarceration in
the last seven years, T***sition Age Youth (TAY) head of households, and/or
Domestic Violence Survivors head of households; and
e. Within 180 days, return with a recommendation for long-term Countywide
administration of such an Initiative.MOTION BY SUPERVISORS HOLLY J. MITCHELL AND SHEILA KUEHL
MAY 18, 2021
PAGE 5
4) Direct the CEO to recommend and advocate for relevant legislative policies that improve
outcomes and reduce racial disparities and support local, regional, state, and federal
initiatives that support Guaranteed Income as a poverty alleviation policy and that facilitate
full receipt of all state and Federal benefits regardless of participation in a Guaranteed
Income program.
https://trishintel.com/la-county-proposes-1000-monthly-guaranteed-income/
May 17, 2021 14:38:49 #
Oldsailor65 wrote:
LA County Proposes $1,000 Monthly Guaranteed Incom... (show quote)
It's over, OldSailor
May 17, 2021 15:08:10 #
WinkyTink
Loc: Hill Country, TX
Giving a new name to another welfare program will not improve the effectiveness of welfare over the past 60 years.
It is inflationary. Big Mac's are going up in price in the Guaranteed welfare income hoods.
It will create more "welfare mothers, make better lovers!"
It is inflationary. Big Mac's are going up in price in the Guaranteed welfare income hoods.
It will create more "welfare mothers, make better lovers!"
May 17, 2021 15:45:37 #
Oldsailor65 wrote:
LA County Proposes $1,000 Monthly Guaranteed Incom... (show quote)
I'm from Chicago and I think that is a great idea to eliminate the homeless problem, in Chicago. We should charter buses and offer a free ride to Los Angeles for all of our homeless. We can even get a few trucks to pack their shopping carts into, along with their tents, etc. And it will clean up a big problem under our bridges and eliminate pan handling all at once. And those homeless won't have to stand in the middle of traffic humiliating them selves begging for handouts.
May 17, 2021 16:10:17 #
WinkyTink
Loc: Hill Country, TX
Put a keg on the bus and hand them all a bottle of Ripple as they board!
San Fran also makes for a good destination.
San Fran also makes for a good destination.
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.