Blade_Runner wrote:
There is a book out there titled Deep Survival: Who lives, who dies, and Why.
Lawrence Gonzales, the author, provides anecdotal evidence that trying to intellectually reason through a life threatening circumstance can get you k**led. Intelligence has nothing to do with it. The emotional and physiological responses to life threatening situations can overwhelm the instincts embedded in our DNA.
In one chapter, the author is aboard a US Navy aircraft carrier. He is in the pilot's ready room attending the pilots' pre-flight briefing for their first night landing quals. The Landing Signal Officer, who is responsible for guiding the pilots to a landing back on the carrier in a way that doesn't get anybody k**led, is giving the pilots their briefing. Here's what the LSO told them:
"You're at the quarter mile and someone asks you who your mother is: you don't know. That's how focused you are. Okay, call the ball (land the aircraft). Now it's a knife fight in a phone booth. Remember, full power in the wire. Your IQ rolls back to that of an ape."
And Gonzales writes: It sounds as if he's being a smart ass, but deep lessons also are there to be teased out like some obscure Talmudic script. Lessons about survival, about what you need to know and what you don't need to know. About the surface of the brain and its deep recesses. About what you know that you don't know you know and about what you don't know that you'd better not think you know.
Call it an ape, call it a horse, as Plato did. Plato understood that emotions could trump reason and that to succeed we have to use the reins of reason on the horse of emotion. That turns out to be remarkably close to what modern research has begun to show us, and it works both ways. The intellect without the emotions is like the jockey without the horse.
IOW, if you are not emotionally and mentally prepared to deal with a life threatening situation, your natural instincts to stay alive can easily be overwhelmed.
Oddly, as Gonzales reiterates throughout the book, one human response to life threatening situations can make all the difference - a sense of humor.
There is a book out there titled i Deep Survival:... (
show quote)
Excellent post, and I think a person has to be in that kind circumstance just once, to know exactly what he's talking about, and I think he's dead on correct.