OPP poll.........President Trump's Taxes: Tomorrow Supreme Court will decide if President Trump has give up his Tax returns ....What do you think they will decide??? Judge Napolitano...

proud republican Loc: RED CALIFORNIA

Tomorrow Supreme Court will decide if President Trump has give up his Tax returns ....What do you think they will decide??? Judge Napolitano said it could be split NO for Congress Oversight , but YES for US District Court of New York

EconomistDon

proud republican wrote:

Tomorrow Supreme Court will decide if President Trump has give up his Tax returns ....What do you think they will decide???

I think they should decide correctly that the Constitution does not require release of the President's tax return. We have several excellent Constitutionalist judges, including our latest addition, Brett Kavanaugh. They should know that it is not a Constitution requirement; it is merely a hope among Democrats to find dirt on Trump. Therefore, there is no compelling reason to require release of the tax returns. To do so would only feed a political vendetta. Democrats will have to be content to look at older returns that have already been released.

It is interesting, though, that the Constitution DOES require that the President be a natural-born citizen. And that is something that Obama NEVER proved. A f**e birth Certificate proves nothing.

Sicilianthing

proud republican wrote:

Tomorrow Supreme Court will decide if President Trump has give up his Tax returns ....What do you think they will decide??? Judge Napolitano said it could be split NO for Congress Oversight , but YES for US District Court of New York

>>>

Idk but Trump is seriously screwed if they get the green light on all the Criminality of the Deutsche Bank escapades with Trumpy and his ilk...

proud republican Loc: RED CALIFORNIA

Sicilianthing wrote:

>>>

Idk but Trump is seriously screwed if they get the green light on all the Criminality of the Deutsche Bank escapades with Trumpy and his ilk...

I'm convinced that he is surrounded by the enemies from his own party !

PeterS

proud republican wrote:

I'm convinced that he is surrounded by the enemies from his own party !

Yeah, that's why they all do wh**ever he says...

PeterS

EconomistDon wrote:

I think they should decide correctly that the Cons... (show quote)

What amazes me is that the liberal POWERS THAT BE set the course for Obama to be president from the moment he was born. Clever somes-a-b***hes weren't they...

PeterS

proud republican wrote:

I'm convinced that he is surrounded by the enemies from his own party !

It's more like he's surrounded by enemies in his own family. Mary Trumps book on him is scathing. She is a clinical psychologist and she rips him a new one. "Too Much and Never Enough: How My Family Created the World's Most Dangerous Man," his niece Mary L. Trump comes closer than anyone to describing the making of a seemingly heartless person who won his way to the White House. On page after page of this book, to be published next Tuesday, the author relies on her perspective as an insider and her expertise as a psychologist to reveal the family dynamic that produced a person capable of the kind of outrageous acts Trump has committed. This is, after all, a man who used insult, r****m, and lies to gain and maintain power. A president whose leadership contributed to lethal fiascos involving asylum-seeking children, hurricane victims and, now, a p******c made far worse by his bungling. Through it, he has seemed immune to feelings of regret, grief, and empathy.

She probably describes him more accurately than anyone before her...

rafterman Loc: South Florida

proud republican wrote:

Tomorrow Supreme Court will decide if President Trump has give up his Tax returns ....What do you think they will decide??? Judge Napolitano said it could be split NO for Congress Oversight , but YES for US District Court of New York

The Constitution DOES NOT require the release of the President's tax return - so, the Supreme Court SHOULD decide as such. But, all it takes is for one "supposed" Conservative Judge - like Roberts for example - to decide that even though no past President has been required to release their tax returns but because this is Trump - he's gotta release them. Even if they decide that he must release them if I were Trump it would take me until E******n Day to release them. However, I don't think SCOTUS will rule against Trump.

Tiptop789 Loc: State of Denial

EconomistDon wrote:

I think they should decide correctly that the Cons... (show quote)

Another trump supporter books passage on the SS Trumtanic. Trump's siren song, Obama can't ready be a citizen (because of his name). Forget that the State of HI has his birth certificate. Forget that the Clintons probably checked this out also. Of course your hoping beyond hope (like trump) they his newly appointed friends will side with him. Oh, btw, Congress does have a right to see them. You may want to go back & study the law books further. Where did you get them, trump university? He's going to release them anyway as soon as the audit is over. You may want to bring an extra life jacket on your voyage.

Tiptop789 Loc: State of Denial

proud republican wrote:

Tomorrow Supreme Court will decide if President Trump has give up his Tax returns ....What do you think they will decide??? Judge Napolitano said it could be split NO for Congress Oversight , but YES for US District Court of New York

An interesting topic

Lonewolf

rafterman wrote:

The Constitution DOES NOT require the release of t... (show quote)

The law says if congress asks for them the government shall supply them.
He said he would, but that was just another lie.
When congress asked for Nixon's they got them the same day!
Just about all presidents have voluntarily released theirs.
The difference between them and trump, simple trumps a crook.

Lonewolf

proud republican wrote:

Tomorrow Supreme Court will decide if President Trump has give up his Tax returns ....What do you think they will decide??? Judge Napolitano said it could be split NO for Congress Oversight , but YES for US District Court of New York

Funny they wouldn't need to decide this if trump kept his promise to release them.

rafterman Loc: South Florida

Tiptop789 wrote:

Another trump supporter books passage on the SS Tr... (show quote)

Just read the constitution Tiptop789. There are lots of places on the internet that you can read it plus there are some smartphone apps that make it really handy to have at your fingertips.

In order to override the Constitution, Congress would have to pass a law. What is the law? Can you cite "Oh, btw, Congress does have a right to see them"? I would happily get on the bandwagon and ensure Trump releases his tax returns IF IT IS THE LAW. Sorry to be a doubting Thomas on this my friend, but just because someone in Congress has said that Congress has the right doesn't make it so. Senators and Congressman say that Congress has a right to do a lot of things just to intimidate or for political purposes. Both sides do it on a day to day basis.

proud republican Loc: RED CALIFORNIA

Supreme Court sends case on on Trump's Grand Jury subpoena back to lower court....What does it mean ???????

rafterman Loc: South Florida

proud republican wrote:

Supreme Court sends case on on Trump's Grand Jury subpoena back to lower court....What does it mean ???????

Trump’s taxes may be released to grand jury, supreme court rules – See this https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/live/2020/jul/09/scotus-donald-trump-tax-returns-us-c****av***s-news-f***i-

Supreme court sends congressional subpoenas case back to lower court

The supreme court has issued its second opinion in cases related to subpoenas of the president’s financial records.

It is another 7-2 decision written by Chief Justice John Roberts, and it calls for sending the case back to the lower court to more closely review concerns over the separation of powers.

“The courts below did not take adequate account of the significant separation of powers concerns implicated by congressional subpoenas for the President’s information,” Roberts wrote in the decision.

The opinion is not a total victory for Trump, but it does buy him time in the case, virtually ensuring the matter won’t be settled until after the November e******n.